PolishForums   Travel to Poland 
Home . Polls . Search Witamy,  [Guest 38.103.63.58]  Latest Threads . Unanswered Threads . Random Thread
 Please REGISTER or login below:

 » Username:  » Password: 
  [forgot password?]

Polish Forums / Poland Genealogy / Start a new topic in the [Poland Genealogy] forum

I am not Polish enough :-(


  «« 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7  »»
messages: 195
Lady in red [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 12:33  #61

Except the Americans of course :) They're not Europeans YET !! Lol.

Reply
Guest

Patrycja19
  Jul 15, 07, 12:37  #62

Quoting: Lady in red
They're not Europeans YET !! Lol.


I was told I looked very european.. my only hope is when I come to visit I dont
get thrown our for messin up on my Polish :)))

Reply
Member
Threads: 63
Posts: 3141
Joined: Oct 31, 06
truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 12:49  #63

Quoting: Lady in red
Doesn't really matter does it ? We're all Europeans now :) We all share some of the same genes, somewhere along the lines........even if it was a long time ago :)

That's quite inportant for people in Belarus , ex-Litwa.
They are told by Polish and Russians that their ethnic group was able only to be a peasant, not szlachtic. That is a damageful. People should know more than 10 per cent of their compatriots were from szlachta, they called themselves untill the 19 century litwiny. They were Belorussians and Lithanians although spoke Polish (as Irish people speak English)

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
Lady in red [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 12:57  #64

Sorry :(

I didn't realise how important it was to you.

Reply
Guest

Big Rob
  Jul 15, 07, 12:58  #65

Quoting: Lady in red
Doesn't really matter does it ? We're all Europeans now :) We all share some of the same genes, somewhere along the lines........even if it was a long time ago :)


Just wanted to say that I agree with you 100%.

Reply
Member
Threads: -
Posts: 85
Joined: Mar 10, 07
Lady in red [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 13:15  #66

Quoting: Big Rob
Just wanted to say that I agree with you 100%.


Hi Rob, yeah I think that's what we should all be proud of now. Feels good too, I think.
Thanks :)

Reply
Guest

truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 13:20  #67

Poles and Lithanians were also from a united RP. That didn't keep such people as Adam Mickiewicz away from his Litwin origin. The first words of his Pan adeusz are: Litwa my Motherland...

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
ola123 [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 13:27  #68

Quoting: truhlei
Poles and Lithanians were also from a united RP. That didn't keep such people as Adam Mickiewicz away from his Litwin origin. The first words of his Pan adeusz are: Litwa my Motherland...



Are you Russian, Lithuanian, Polish? Just asking.

Reply
Guest

opts
  Jul 15, 07, 13:29  #69

You are Polish, when your heart tells you so. :)

Reply
Member
Threads: 8
Posts: 205
Joined: Jul 29, 06
truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 13:33  #70

Quoting: ola123
Are you Russian, Lithuanian, Polish? Just asking

Russian by Belief and citizenship bur my mother had origin in Litwa

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
ola123 [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 13:47  #71

Interesting mix.

Reply
Guest

truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 14:00  #72

Quoting: ola123
Interesting mix

Each country consists of such mixes.
Millions of people in Russia has ancestors from Litwa and Crown by massive deportations of previous centuries and many people settled for Russia before 1917 by unempoyment.
I was managed to learn my ancestors' history untill 17 century because they presented it to Szlachetska comission for szlachta confirmation in 1840-1850. Three ancestors families past became evident. My mothe knew only names of her grandfathers because it was dangerous to tell anything about non-proletarian or non-peasant past of family to little children in 1930-1940/ When she became a grown-up everybody was dead.
Many people in Russia in such situation

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
witek
  Jul 15, 07, 14:07  #73

Quoting: truhlei
Adam Mickiewicz away from his Litwin origin. The first words of his Pan adeusz are: Litwa my Motherland...


By calling Lithuania his "Fatherland" Mickiewicz was refering to a region of the former Polish-Lithuanian Commenwealth he loved. Let us not forget that Mickiewicz wrote his masterpieces in Polish and that he was a Polish patriot as he died in Turkey raising Polish forces to fight against the Russians in the Crimean War in 1855.

Reply
Member
Threads: 2
Posts: 778
Joined: Apr 1, 07
truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 14:17  #74

Quoting: witek
By calling Lithuania his "Fatherland" Mickiewicz was refering to a region of the former Polish-Lithuanian Commenwealth he loved. Let us not forget that Mickiewicz wrote his masterpieces in Polish

Language doesn't shows etnicity in any case. Irish people speak English. That doesn't mean they are Englishmen.
Of course Mickiewicz was a Lithanian-Polish unity in one state partisan. Nobody may oppose to that idea because we see it in his works. But we also should agree that people Litwa in his epoch called themselves Litwins, not Polish people. They were Polish only for foreigners.
I don't think we should follow the ideas of oficial Poland of 1918-1939 that renamed Litwa as Kresy and also renamed Brest-Litowski.

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
witek
  Jul 15, 07, 14:26  #75

Quoting: truhlei
Language doesn't shows etnicity in any case


'Scratch a Russian and you'll find a Tatar'

Reply
Member
Threads: 2
Posts: 778
Joined: Apr 1, 07
truhlei
  Jul 15, 07, 16:22  #76

Quoting: witek
'Scratch a Russian and you'll find a Tatar'

Scratch a Polish szlachtic and you will also find a Tatar.
You deal with ius sanguis, blood law.
I deal with ius soli, ground law.
Russians have not only Tatars among ancestors but also tribes similar to today Finland residents and many turk tribes appeared in this region since 6 century. But Russia is not called Tataria since 1480 and never was called Suomi.
As to Litwa it had such name in difference with Crown (Poland) even after Lublin Union.
Untill 1795 Litwins didn't call themselves Poles.
Now Litwa is apart from Poland. Two states Belarus and Litvania occupy its territory.
That's the reason why I think My ancestors were from Litwa not for Poland despite speaking Polish

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
Osiedle_Ruda [Guest]
  Jul 15, 07, 18:22  #77

Quoting: ola123
Ok Im 95%-100% polish so Im not very polish................................ erm now that doesnt make sense at all


hehe... unfortunately I was born in England, but I have 100% Polish parents - does that mean I have more right to buy a flat in Poland than ola123 has, or not? lol ;) :D

Reply
Guest

ola123 [Guest]
  Jul 16, 07, 11:31  #78

Quoting: Osiedle_Ruda
hehe... unfortunately I was born in England, but I have 100% Polish parents - does that mean I have more right to buy a flat in Poland than ola123 has, or not? lol ;) :D


I have more rights coz I was born here and I work here nanananana :P Read my post on the other thread.

Reply
Guest

El Gamal
  Jul 16, 07, 15:26  #79

Quoting: truhlei
As to Litwa it had such name in difference with Crown (Poland) even after Lublin Union.Untill 1795 Litwins didn't call themselves Poles.Now Litwa is apart from Poland. Two states Belarus and Litvania occupy its territory. That's the reason why I think My ancestors were from Litwa not for Poland despite speaking Polish


You seems to be intelligent and well educated person, but IMO in this case, you are mixing several things and don't understand some. Compare Polish community in Kresy (now western Ukraine, Belarus and Lithuania) to German one on former German land (now western Poland). Germans living there were Germans, similarly Poles living in the Kresy were Poles. They called themselves Poles, spoke Polish, were held within Polish culture, had Polish parents, etc.... After hundrets of years of Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth Poles were emigrating in the east and this fact didn't make Lithuanians of them.

About Mickiewicz: for me he did more bad things to Poles that good, so if Lithuanians want to take him, let them do it :D. We had more noble Poles and it's better to look among mathematitians and engineers rather than poets.

About you: YES, some of your ancestors were Polish (I know it hurts in contemporary Putin-rulled Russia). Remember not to tell it to anybody, it's dangerous for your teeth ;).

Reply
Member
Threads: 2
Posts: 30
Joined: Jul 1, 07
blackadder
  Jul 16, 07, 15:36  #80

if you aren't polish enogh,then polish yourselve more;))
ok,bad one I know...i couldn't resist

Reply
Member
Threads: 1
Posts: 205
Joined: Jun 28, 07
tornado2007
  Jul 16, 07, 16:32  #81

To the author of this topic:

Don't feel bad the closest thing i've got to Poland is that i once had a polish girlfriend, LOL

I'm about three or four different nationalities and i count myself as all of them :)

Reply
Member
Threads: 21
Posts: 2791
Joined: Jul 11, 07
shopgirl
  Jul 16, 07, 20:57  #82

I'm not Polish enough either. :(

Reply
Member
Threads: 10
Posts: 1780
Joined: Apr 6, 07
Qacer
  Jul 16, 07, 21:45  #83

I had someone Polish on me, but I don't think that counts. ;-)

Reply
Member
Threads: 36
Posts: 144
Joined: Jul 9, 07
beckski
  Jul 16, 07, 23:26  #84

Quoting: Qacer
I had someone Polish on me, but I don't think that counts. ;-)


Boy or girl?

Reply
Member
Threads: 8
Posts: 530
Joined: May 15, 07
sledz ♦ GOLD MEMBER
  Jul 16, 07, 23:40  #85

Quoting: shopgirl
I'm not Polish enough either. :(



Slainte agus tainte :)

Reply
Member
Threads: 20
Posts: 2476
Joined: Sep 19, 06
Osiedle_Ruda [Guest]
  Jul 17, 07, 11:43  #86

Quoting: shopgirl
I'm not Polish enough either. :(


I'm 100% Polish but that's still not Polish enough for ola123. ;)

Reply
Guest

truhlei
  Jul 17, 07, 12:22  #87

Quoting: El Gamal
similarly Poles living in the Kresy were Poles. They called themselves Poles, spoke Polish, were held within Polish culture, had Polish parents, etc....

There vere imigrants from Poland in Litwa but the majority of Polish-speakink szlachta People were Ruthenians and Zmud (ethnic Lithanians) by origin. They felt a unity with Pole szlachta but we have few evidence they called Poles themselves. The lists of szlachta in Grodno at the beginning of 19 century shows us that people called themselves bielaruska or litowska szlachta (sorry for spelling).
Most of them spoked Polish (as well as Bielorussian) but they didn't feel themselves Poles by ground (lex soli). There was still a difference between Crown and Litwa.
As to the imigrants, most of them were really naturalized there as people from Bogatyrowiczi described by Elisa Orgezkowa.
My version is that thei felt themselves Poles alter Poland received status of Kingsdom and Litwa passed to be Russian Gubernijas. The second reason was the liquidation of Uniate Chirch. Greek-Catholics gave the feeling of some national unanimity within Litwa: 80 per cent of peasants and at least 25 per cent of poor szlachta. When Greek Catholicism dissapeared Roman Catholics and former Greek Catholics passed to Roman rite felt themselves in minority and the wish to feel themselves within a great catholic nation appeared.
I'm sure this is common with 19 centuri not before.
This is my version. Historians in Belarus (except oficial) support this idea

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
truhlei
  Jul 17, 07, 12:24  #88

Quoting: El Gamal
About Mickiewicz: for me he did more bad things to Poles that good, so if Lithuanians want to take him, let them do it :D. We had more noble Poles and it's better to look among mathematitians and engineers rather than poets.

I shall agree with you. Heretics such as Mickiewicz were enough damageful.
But as to his intuition of Fatherland, well I think it was not only common with him.

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
peterweg
  Jul 17, 07, 12:27  #89

Quoting: Osiedle_Ruda
'm 100% Polish but that's still not Polish enough for ola123. ;)


What would she know, she a bloody foreigner :)

Reply
Member
Threads: 17
Posts: 510
Joined: Feb 16, 07
truhlei
Edited by: truhlei  Jul 17, 07, 12:27  #90

Quoting: El Gamal
Remember not to tell it to anybody, it's dangerous for your teeth ;).

Now it is not dangerous especially among middle classers.
Old Victorian Polish speking middle class is still in memory and respect among Russian middle classers.
They hate contemporary Polish behaviour presented in the films and in private contacts: angry agressive and inmoral.
Gamal I'd like to invite you to a discussion http://www.polishforums.com/poland_russia_never_ending_story-4_11550_0 .html As ro me it seems to be very interesting

Reply
Member
Threads: 15
Posts: 631
Joined: Jul 15, 07
 
  «« 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 7  »» Similar Threads | Latest | Unanswered | Random  Go UPtop of page

Home / Poland Genealogy /

Your Reply re: I am not Polish enough :-( 

Bold  Italic  Horizontal Line  Cite Source 
Polish letters: Ą  ą  Ć  ć  Ę  ę  Ł  ł  Ń  ń  Ó  ó  Ś  ś  Ź  ź  Ż  ż

If you read this, you are probably not a registered user yet and cannot access all forums and features!

 - Before creating a new thread, make sure to follow the Thread Title Creation Rules.
 - Your message must comply with the General Forum Rules.
 - If you have further questions, check the Forum FAQ & Feedback section.

To post anonymously, please enter a temporary and unique username (without password).


To login and post as a member, please enter your registered username and password.

 » Username:  » Password: 



Newer thread in this forum: Older thread in this forum:
Preczewski in Poznan area arczynski--surname


196 users online in the last hour [Guests - 136 / Members - 60] Forum times are CST [GMT -6] / Time in Poland: 22:24

Home . Latest Threads . Unanswered Threads . Random Thread . Statistics

© 2005-2009 PolishForums.com | About Us | Contact Us | Privacy, TOS, Rules | Poland Advertising |