PolishForums - ARCHIVE   PolishForums Archive :
Archives / 2008 / History / 133

What Happened in the Danzig Corridor 1939? Poles Slaughtering Germans?




joepilsudski Activity: 28 / 1,420
Joined: 27 Apr 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #1
I have always been confused about the historical reality of what happened in the Danzig corridor in 1939, which many claim was the direct provocation for the German attack on Poland...I picked out a 'revisionist' article about from the web, as a starting point for discussion...do we have some historians, professors or students who might wish to give a Polish version of the events?...the Polish leadership, under Beck and his two associates seem to have miscalculated events.

ihr.org/jhr/v04/v04p205_Hoggan.html

Goonie Activity: 9 / 242
Joined: 6 Mar 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #2
isn't that when Russian soldiers executed a ton of poles?

celinski Activity: 32 / 1,273
Joined: 14 Nov 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #3
This site tell this part of history well. Carol
The act of war: AD 1939


During the night of August 31 a group of German soldiers, dressed as Poles, attack the German radio station in the border town of Gleiwitz. They have brought with them a German criminal, taken for the purpose from a concentration camp. They shoot him and leave his body as evidence of the night's dark deeds.

Berlin radio broadcasts to the world the news of this act of Polish aggression, together with details of the necessary German response. In the early hours of the morning of September 1 Hitler's tanks move into Poland. His planes take off towards Warsaw on the first bombing mission of a new European war.

historyworld.net/wrldhis/PlainTextHistories.asp?ParagraphID=ogj

joepilsudski Activity: 28 / 1,420
Joined: 27 Apr 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #4
No, Celinski...I know about that...in 1939 many Germans were massacred in the Danzig corridor, some claim by Poles, some say 'bolsheviks'...this was the event that directly provoked the German invasion...did the Poles commit these acts for any or no particular reason?...and did this act have the support of the Polish government, or was it an act committed by bolsheviks?

plk123 Activity: 11 / 4,276
Joined: 29 Aug 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #5
joe, are you a szwab or something? that was the story spun by hitler. i am not so sure if it's true at all.

celinski Activity: 32 / 1,273
Joined: 14 Nov 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #6
an act committed by bolsheviks?

That was nothing but a big fat lie.

I found a debating Forum on this subject, check it out.

debatingforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=1024&view=previous&sid=610bd6f87075ef36d7533436f74ed726

Lukasz Activity: 56 / 1,788
Joined: 1 Sep 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #7
No, Celinski...I know about that...in 1939 many Germans were massacred in the Danzig corridor, some claim by Poles, some say 'bolsheviks'...this was the event that directly provoked the German invasion...did the Poles commit these acts for any or no particular reason?...and did this act have the support of the Polish government, or was it an act committed by bolsheviks?



bolsheviks in 1939 in western Poland ? Provokations ? ... Joe ... I think you have problems with history ... I don't know what is mainstream history in USA ... I feel it is much different than in Poland.

El Gato Activity: 4 / 355
Joined: 21 Sep 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #8
Take it from me...the history books have HUGE differences and much different accounts of the same events in the USA vs Poland.

celinski Activity: 32 / 1,273
Joined: 14 Nov 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #9
I don't know what is mainstream history in USA


Lots of room for improvement in USA, more is passed through family history.

Bratwurst Boy Activity: 5 / 8,008
Joined: 2 Apr 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #10
In Germany we call it "Bromberger Blutsonntag" and it happened!

de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bromberger_Blutsonntag

Bye

Dzhaklin Activity: 3 / 170
Joined: 3 Dec 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #11

Take it from me...the history books have HUGE differences and much different accounts of the same events in the USA vs Poland.


This is very very true.

plk123 Activity: 11 / 4,276
Joined: 29 Aug 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #12
In Germany we call it "Bromberger Blutsonntag" and it happened!

nothing like retiliating against boy scouts and such.. oh the brave nazis. *rollleyes*

This is very very true

part of this is that in PL real historical events have been suppressed ever sinc ethe commies.. thing sare just coming to light now. eventually the histories will be much closer.

Dzhaklin Activity: 3 / 170
Joined: 3 Dec 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #13

part of this is that in PL real historical events have been surpressed ever sinc ethe commies.. thing sare just coming to light now. eventually the histories will be much closer.



Yeah I know that and believe me I've seen textbooks from other countries that basically invented history themselves. Things have come a long way since the fall of communism

joepilsudski Activity: 28 / 1,420
Joined: 27 Apr 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #14
joe, are you a szwab or something? that was the story spun by hitler. i am not so sure if it's true at all.


This is what I was referring to...what is the meaning of this?...is there truth here?

judicial-inc.biz/Broomberg.htm

Dzhaklin Activity: 3 / 170
Joined: 3 Dec 2007 ♀
  7 Apr 2008 /  #15
This is what I was referring to...what is the meaning of this?...is there truth here?


Well it's not exactly the most reputable reference I've ever seen.

Lukasz Activity: 56 / 1,788
Joined: 1 Sep 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #16
joepilsudski 


Joe your ststements are so idiotic that I am not going to discusse it. Poles and Jews killing Germans ? Bolsheviks in western Poland (LOL) before WWII ?!? you are sick...

it is good that you edited this part of your post ...

Jozef Pilsudski Activity: - / 25
Joined: 15 Mar 2008 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #17
In fact, it was ethnic Poles massacred in various areas of Silesia throughout the interwar period, not ethnic Germans in Danzig. This sounds like old war propaganda used by the German government at the time to justify the Wehrmacht's invasion of Polish territory and the destruction of Warsaw.

plk123 Activity: 11 / 4,276
Joined: 29 Aug 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #18
judicial-inc.biz/Broomberg.htm

i can't fathom how this site could be construed as anything but crazy. do you believe any of it to be true?

did you read about the part that poland was actually threatening the nazis? if that ain't a sad joke, i dunno what is.

they say in there that bydgoszcz was given to PL after the ww1.. how about RETURNED?

In fact, it was ethnic Poles massacred in various areas of Silesia throughout the interwar period, not ethnic Germans in Danzig. This sounds like old war propaganda used by the German government at the time to justify the Wehrmacht's invasion of Polish territory and the destruction of Warsaw.

yes, the Polish Menace.

Dice Activity: 15 / 459
Joined: 27 Nov 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #19
In Germany we call it "Bromberger Blutsonntag" and it happened!

Bromberger Blutsonntag

Here it is in English: URL

It is hard to say how many Germans died exclusively during the Bloody Sunday. German author Peter Aurich gave a number of German civilian deaths in Bydgoszcz as 366 deaths.[8], another German historian, Hugo Rasmus, estimates the number of ethnic German deaths in Bydgoszcz as "at least 415".[1] Two Polish historians - Włodzimierz Jastrzębski and Czesław Madajczyk against the Polish soldiers in the city, estimate ethnic German deaths respectively 103 (Jastrzębski), and about 300 (150 on September 3, the rest in the days after) victims (Madajczyk).[9]

It looks like there was a massacre of the German minority in town of Bydgoszcz two days after the German invasion of Poland.

I've never heard about it, have you?

I have always been confused about the historical reality of what happened in the Danzig corridor in 1939, which many claim was the direct provocation for the German attack on Poland...


The massacre in Bydgoszcz accrued two days AFTER the start of the invasion.

plk123 Activity: 11 / 4,276
Joined: 29 Aug 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #20
this bydgoszcz thing is new on me too but there was some weird events just around that time.. i think it was gdansk.. i'll search around and see if it comes to me.

Jozef Pilsudski Activity: - / 25
Joined: 15 Mar 2008 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #21
It looks like there was a massacre of the German minority in town of Bydgoszcz two days after the German invasion of Poland.

I've never heard about it, have you?


This sounds like an entirely justified massacre to me.


sinistar Activity: - / 12
Joined: 18 Dec 2007 ♂
  7 Apr 2008 /  #23
euhm, all I can say is that US ppl should come get some history lessons in europe to get the real story of annything in history doing to world wars etc.

Ozi Dan Activity: 27 / 569
Joined: 22 Nov 2007 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #24
Thanks for the post plk. It appears the answers to Pilsudski's questions may lie in the sources contained in references 14 to 16 of plk's post on Operation Himmler.

Bratwurst Boy Activity: 5 / 8,008
Joined: 2 Apr 2007 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #25

This sounds like an entirely justified massacre to me.


Yeah...well...so was the whole polish campaign! :)

Matyjasz Activity: 2 / 1,547
Joined: 20 Jul 2006 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #26

Jozef Pilsudski:

This sounds like an entirely justified massacre to me.


Yeah...well...so was the whole polish campaign! :)



Don't forget the shape of the Polish western border after the WWII. :):)

Bratwurst Boy Activity: 5 / 8,008
Joined: 2 Apr 2007 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #27
And still the Poles like to see themselves as victims after all they gained...can you believe it! :)

plk123 Activity: 11 / 4,276
Joined: 29 Aug 2007 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #28
why are you being that way.. pommerania historically has always been polish not german. silesia has always been pretty well mixed. what do you mean by gains? we lost half of our eastern territories.

justified? i sure hope the turks in your own country show you justified. just throwing crap out here without any back up is so freaking nazi of you.

Matyjasz Activity: 2 / 1,547
Joined: 20 Jul 2006 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #29
And still the Poles like to see themselves as victims after all they gained...can you believe it! :)



That's because they should have gained much more. :)

Bratwurst Boy Activity: 5 / 8,008
Joined: 2 Apr 2007 ♂
  8 Apr 2008 /  #30
How much more? Some more of Lithuania? Some more of Ukraine? Some more of the Czech Republic? Why not some more of Germany?

Manno, you don't have enough people for all that as they leave Poland in droves to invade other countries for a better living instead to make something out of the land you have...

just throwing crap out here without any back up is so freaking nazi of you.


Somehow I missed your righteous indignation at that:

This sounds like an entirely justified massacre to me.


So please spare me!

page 1 of 5:    1     2    3    4    5    »»
Archives / 2008 / History /Archived