LIVE FORUMS / ARCHIVES / 2009
PolishForums - ARCHIVE Witamy in PolishForums Archive :
Archives / 2009 / News, Politics / posts: 2

Question and Answer with Edward Zwick: Producer of "Defiance"



ela_lawyerThreads: 7
Posts: 95
Joined: Nov 28, 07
Edited by: ela_lawyer   Jan 11, 09, 11:31 /  #
Q: Well before the film's release, the Polish American Journal wrote a story about the movie that said: "The Jewish partisans, who collaborated with the Soviets, are regarded as war criminals by Poles, because their exploits included the massacre of 128 Polish villagers in Naliboki."

A: It's a very complicated issue. First, that story has been refuted by the most serious historians. In fact, the Bielskis were nowhere near that forest at that time. But it's important to say that even if they were, to try to equate Jews participating in some attack on a village, which no doubt was in reprisal for something else, was in the context of wartime, and I'm afraid to say, understandable. This story is very interesting for another reason. In Poland now there is a right-wing government that is enacting something called lustration laws. It's a witch hunt to try to determine which members of the present government had any affiliation with communists. And they're trying to find any connection between Jews and the present elected officials, and to use, again, anti-Semitism as a way to try to further their agenda.


I think Zwick has his facts all wrong. He is attempting to blame a 'right-wing' Polish Government on lustration laws. Perhaps, he better learn his history a bit more. Jews were not immune to war crimes, just as anyone else. They are not a people who are fully exempt from wrong doing.

Interview with Edward Zwick
time meansThreads: 9
Posts: 2,306
Joined: Apr 21, 08
 Pictures: 1
  Jan 11, 09, 12:07 /  #
when has fact ever got in the way of a hollywood picture?

Go UPtop of page


Similar discussions:

Similar to: Question and Answer with Edward Zwick: Producer of "Defiance"
Does anybody else think the movie Defiance is a big lie?
Poor Edward in Kraków
Polish-American Edward Moskal
Question on my name...
A question of gender
a question about włoszczyzna
A question to immigrants
Question: about Tuition fee for Non-EU
Question on diminutives (Stefan and Ewa)
A question regarding this Christmas gift...

wloszczowa station  Anyone ever seen a Mikrus (car)?

Random: Ukraine famine documents released.
Archives / 2009 / News, Politics /posts: 2


This forum is archived (read-only).
Category:
© 2005-2010 PolishForums.com | PolishForums LIVE | Archives | Random | Statistics