IS "MURZYN" word RACIST?

Black footballer Paulo Ferreira, who plays on Poland's national squad, said the word "Murzyn" in Polish is racist. Most Poles believe it to be is a netural, descriptive, generic term with no racial overtones. "Czarnuch" would be offensive.
He also said Tuwim's "Murzynek Bambo" should be removed from schools and lirbaries. Do you agree?

Czarnuch is much stronger but Murzyn, with the correct intonation, is racist. Neutral my ass.

So people with Murzyn as a surname have a racist surname?

if i want to buy 'black coffee' in the coffee shop in the us, should i rather ask for 'afroamerican coffee'?

;)

i used to know a family with the last name Murzyn... nobody was making any jokes about them...

There is the English surname Ramsbottom. It is still rude to call someone a ram's bottom, eh Seanus?

My ass is hip slang, like my n****. Yo, my ass it ain't

Hmm...the above proves that it's my bed time :(

???

Being in the farmyard, perhaps we should familiarise ourselves with calf slang.

well its hard topic... im from poland and when i say " Murzyn " i dont have nothing bad on mind, as far as i know those few black ppl they dont get it as offensive. And yea i belive " Czarnuch " it is offensive for me . But still this is very hard for black ppl to notice when someone offending them and when not. I play football with black ppl sometimes and rly i can say anything and they dont get it as a abusive, but same word in someone else mounth can hurt them rly bad... its about black ppl fears and suspicion about all non black... and i understand that ofc. its about time, more dif color skin ppl gona come to poland and then in few yr all that racist topics in tv,net etc will die. Ofc there goan be always some racist like in every country but we cant do anything with that. And Murzynek Bambo in same way can be taken as racist but i bet when Tuwim was writing it, he dont mind about anything like that. Those times (1894-1915) ppl, wasnt think in this way, for most poles someone black was almost same amazing as UFO so text " Murzynek Bambo w Afryce mieszkal" (Murzynek Bambo was living in Africa) was more like imagination about black ppl not racist poem.

??? indeed. Ferreira plays for Portugal.

& hes aint negro

A word in itself, and here I mean any word, is not offensive but the intentions can be. The word "murzyn" for me is a neutral word, however it can be used as a derogatory word if the person who uses it will have the intentions to offend.

Let’s take the word Paki for example. For a person from the US it’s just a short form of the word Pakistani. Nothing insulting about that. The situation is totally different in the UK where the word Paki is commonly known as a very racist term. It’s all about intentions.

And “Murzynek Bambo” is definitely not racist.

What should a man called 'Dick' think?..

I might agree if it would be "Murzynek Sambo"

http://www.moikrewni.pl/mapa/kompletny/murzyn.html

There is 2600 people with Murzyn surname in Poland. I doubt that they are black or they fell offended when somebody uses their surname...

I don't find Murzyn racist.

Ahh but have you met all of them? ;)




Or DICKinSON? ;)

Yuk. Death penalty, huh? ^^

Long Live Political Correctness, whoo-hoo!!!!!

Problem is we don't have anything else in Polish than "murzyn". Do we? What else we can call black peoples from Africa so not to offend them?

kuntakinte

Afrikanczycy? lol...

Afropolacy

I'm really annoyed by all that political correctness. Soon, each language and culture will have to loose their identity and references just because it annoys some minority. When it's not some minority, it's another one. Can't people just accept who they are?

I worked with a girl who married a guy called Hardcok - now that's an offensive surname :)



Nope, what will happen will be a lot of PC rubbish and having books removed and logos removed and anything else that might offend the guests in your country!

Should Cilla Black change her surname? Oh and my friend has an uncle Paki (pet name for Patrick in Ireland)

Welcome to our lovely multi-cultural society :)

I used to know a man named Michael Hunt, he was known as Mike, honestly that's true, he had a real hang up about it

My aunt used to teach a young man from a religious family with the same surname. They called him Isaac.

True story.



It's all about context, as has already been demonstrated:

Q. IS "MURZYN" word RACIST?

A. Not at all it's who they are

MURZYN wasn't racist until the fashion for political correctness was imported to Poland from the US :P Without PC nobody would even think there can be something offensive about. Any word can be offensive if used with such intention. The racist word in Polish is CZARNUCH.

I've heard that African immigrants (mainly African students :) ) want themselves to be called CZARNOSKÓRZY (lit. black-skinned). But for me it's artificial.

Lets ban murzynek cake as well.



They should call us białoskórzy (white-skinned) following this logic.

LOL. Or maybe "bladolicy"? That just sounds so silly...

:)) It could have been worse. He could have been called Floppycock. ;)

She already has. She was originally Priscilla White.

How about Gordon Brown? He sits somewhere inbetween. He is a mulat.

A what?

No, it's not a black person, more of a brown one. Ask the Poles

isn't it half white half black person?

Yeah, add the right amount of white to the black and you end up with brown.

that's mulatto or mestiço



isn't black nor polish nor brasilian.. you must be confused


i work with an afrikan america who is 100% white. not sh.tting you either. :D


or they were their slaves anyway.


nope, definitely derogatory in most instances.
nope again. do you just call everybody a nigger then? i am sure that's not racist either as you have no intention of hurting them with that word, right?


the title may not be but in many ways the poem definitely pushes bigoted stereotypes or total myths as a fun way to educate.. that is definitely racist even if the intent wasn't there.


Richard



i don't find nigger offensive either b.tch but "they" surely do.. get it?


there are a lot of white afrikanz.. google it, eh? about half the continent of africa is arabs too.. they are not negros either.


there you go. lol madagascar anyone?


bingo and until the czarnoskorzy showed up.

So my fiancee is not Polish then? She says mulat

Murzyn is not racist. It's how in Poland we call black people. It's the least offensive word describing black person.