PolishForums.com
POLAND . The Unofficial Guide
Unanswered | Archives
Poland and Polish Community Witamy, Guest | PF Members | Gold Members

Polish Forums / History of Poland / Post reply Start a new thread in [History of Poland]

Is Józef Piłsudski the king of modern Poles?


page 2 of 4:  « Prev  1  2  3  4  Next »

BzibziohThreads: 6
Posts: 3,648
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Bzibzioh  Jan 31, 10, 22:05    #31
Bratwurst Boy:
Another altar of his in this church has reliefs depicting six scenes in the life of St. Stanislaus.

That is mystery to me. I know there is fantastic crucifix made by him in the same church but another altar? I doubt it.

"Po stronie północnej (lewej) znajduje się barokowy ołtarz p.w. Św. Stanisława (zamykający lewą nawę boczną) z drugiej połowy XVII wieku z rzeźbioną sceną Wskrzeszenia Piotrowina. Wmontowana jest tu gotycka mensa z ok. 1400 roku z płaskorzeźbną dekoracją.
Drugi barokowy ołtarz, wykonany został w 1725 roku przez architekta krakowskiego Kacpra Bażankę. W nim znajduje się obraz Zwiastowanie, namalowany w 1740 roku przez Giovanni Battistę Pittoniego."

Nope. No mention of Stwosz.

Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Jan 31, 10, 22:11    #32
Bzibzioh:
I doubt it.

You are the expert...I'm only wikiing! *bows out*

:)
BzibziohThreads: 6
Posts: 3,648
Joined: Oct 15, 08
 Jan 31, 10, 22:16    #33
Bratwurst Boy:
You are the expert...

... and don't you forget it, mister!!! :)
SokratesThreads: 19
Posts: 4,464
Joined: Jan 19, 09
[Suspended]
 Jan 31, 10, 22:43    #34
Bratwurst Boy:
That could be as at that time it was the German merchants who made Krakow and other towns prosperous.

Why not the Polish merchants? After all it was the Poles who monopolised the river traffic so what did the Germans have to contribute when most of the wealth was in Polish hands? Exactly the kind of attitude i'm talking about.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Jan 31, 10, 22:50    #35
Sokrates:
After all it was the Poles who monopolised the river traffic so what did the Germans have to contribute when most of the wealth was in Polish hands?

Because Krakau was mainly german till the 16th century and a member of the Hanseatic League?
The contrary was more likely true....

As the capital of a powerful state and a member of the Hanseatic League, the city attracted many craftsmen, businesses, and guilds as science and the arts began to flourish.[15]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League

Kraków, then the capital of Poland, was also a Hansa city with German burghers around 1500.

Sokrates:
Exactly the kind of attitude i'm talking about.

What attitude?
BzibziohThreads: 6
Posts: 3,648
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Bzibzioh  Jan 31, 10, 22:52    #36
Sokrates:
Why not the Polish merchants? After all it was the Poles who monopolised the river traffic so what did the Germans have to contribute when most of the wealth was in Polish hands?

Hanza?

Bratwurst Boy:
Because Krakau was mainly german till the 16th century

Check what king Władysław Łokietek did to German merchants :)
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Jan 31, 10, 22:55    #37
http://www.poloniatoday.com/explore10.htm

KRAKOW

Krakow holds a special place among the Polish towns which were members of the Hanseatic league. The splendor it enjoyed in the late medieval period was not only due to its membership in the union--Krakow of that time was above all the capital and the main administrative center of Poland.
However, as a Hanseatic town, Krakow could participate in the European trade exchange and let its own burghers prosper...
...
Many traces of the Hanseatic period have remained. Admiring them may become a fascinating adventure and unforgettable experience for those tourists who are interested in the European culture. It may also be an opportunity to visit unique monuments, in many cases almost unspoiled by the passage of time.

He:)
Did you know about this?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League#Hanseatic_League_of_New_ Time_.28New_Hansa.29

In 1980, it was decided to re-establish the Hanseatic League as the Hanseatic League of New Time (also known as the New Hansa). It hopes to foster and develop business links and tourism within towns and cities as well as promote cultural exchange.
Apart from old Hanseatic cities, the New Hansa granted membership to some cities which had not been members of the medieval Hansa but had had wide trade connections with the Hansa in the Middle Ages.
The latter include twelve Russian cities, most notably Novgorod, which was a major Russian trade partner of the Hansa in the Middle Ages, even though Russian cities had never been official members of the Hanseatic League.


SokratesThreads: 19
Posts: 4,464
Joined: Jan 19, 09
[Suspended]
 Jan 31, 10, 23:02    #38
Bratwurst Boy:
Because Krakau was mainly german till the 16th century and a member of the Hanseatic League?
The contrary was more likely true....

I'm sorry but thats just a chauvinistic lie, one of your many Kraków throught its history had a Polish majority, calling a Polish capital with a Polish majority and a city that due to grain trade was the most important in Hanseatic league "German" makes you an idiot.

Ps. there was no Hanseatic league without Poland, all grain trade from Ukraine went through Poland, any sort of an embargo f*cked the entire Baltic region over a period of few weeks which happened during several wars with the Teutons when various German princess felt like helping out.

Bratwurst Boy:
What attitude?

Chauvinistic lies? You just called a Polish capital a predominantly German city, as far as i know the absolute peak of Germans in Kraków was about 24% and they moved to the city because it was so prosperous not to make it so.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Jan 31, 10, 23:04    #39
Sokrates:
I'm sorry but thats just a chauvinistic lie, one of your many Kraków throught its history had a Polish majority, calling a Polish capital with a Polish majority and a city that due to grain trade was the most important in Hanseatic league "German" makes you an idiot.

Well...I can't help you if you deny facts...it was founded under the german Magdeburg Law, was till 1500 in it's majority German and got rich in trading within the Hanseatic League (a german trade union) you can call it what you want, but you won't change the facts.

Why don't you just read some of the links and inform yourself...

- The city was almost entirely destroyed during the Mongol invasion of Poland in 1241, after Polish attempts to repulse the invaders had been crushed in the Battle of Chmielnik.

- Kraków was rebuilt in 1257, in a form which was practically unaltered, and received self government city rights based on the Magdeburg Law.

- Kraków was a member of the Hanseatic league and many craftsmen settled there, established businesses and formed craftsmen's guilds.
City Law, including guilds' depictions and descriptions, were recorded in the German language Balthasar Behem Codex.


- In 1475 delegates of the elector George the Rich of Bavaria came to Kraków to negotiate the marriage of Hedwig, the daughter of King Casimir IV Jagiello to George the Rich. Hedwig traveled for two months to Landshut in Bavaria, where an elaborate marriage celebration, the Landshut Wedding (Landshuter Hochzeit 1475) took place in St. Martin's church (Landshut).

Around 1502 Kraków was already featured in the works of Albrecht Dürer as well as in those of Hartmann Schedel (Nuremberg Chronicle) and Georg Braun (Civitates orbis terrarum).

.....

Germans constituted the majority during the 14th century, and became Polonized in the 16th century.[13]


During Krakaus' Golden Age it is a mainly german inhabited town, prospering as member of the german Hanseatic League, many german artists build the most beautiful things in the town....but noooooo, after Sokrates Germans had never anything to do with Kraukau's prosperity and beauty, how dare they, those chauvinistic liars!

Ignoring facts is the means of an idiot!
SokratesThreads: 19
Posts: 4,464
Joined: Jan 19, 09
[Suspended]
 Jan 31, 10, 23:42    #40
BB got anything except for Wiki? No offence but anyone can edit it and for example Nathan regularly edits Wiki articles to fit his view, i know history of Kraków very well and couldnt find a single period when they constituted a majority.

I cant find any Polish source that would confirm your views so either we as Poles practice Soviet school of history (ie falsifying it) or the only place where Germans were a majority in Kraków is on the pages of Wikipedia.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Jan 31, 10, 23:44    #41
Sokrates:
BB got anything except for Wiki?

As far as I can see I'm the only one bringing some facts to the discussion!

You are the one with only an opinion....

Sokrates:
know history of Kraków very well

ROFLMAO!!!
IronsideThreads: 56
Posts: 6,196
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 Jan 31, 10, 23:48    #42
Sokrates:
The name was to call a region of birth, as for his nationality he was from a Polish noble family, with a Polish coat of arms and a long tradition of pro-Polish patriotic activities

its not exactly right, he was from Lithuanian noble family .....but he considered himself Lithuanian in historical sense, but for simplified minds of contemporary cartoon fans - is better to stress that for all practical purpose it explains that he was Polish;P
SokratesThreads: 19
Posts: 4,464
Joined: Jan 19, 09
[Suspended]
 Feb 1, 10, 01:02    #43
Bratwurst Boy:
As far as I can see I'm the only one bringing some facts to the discussion!

You are the one with only an opinion....

Sorry? You're bringing wikipedia and given your outlandish thesis that Kraków had a German minority i'm inclined to believe you either edited it or are aware that its bollocks, find another source.

Ironside:
its not exactly right, he was from Lithuanian noble family .....but he considered himself Lithuanian in historical sense, but for simplified minds of contemporary cartoon fans - is better to stress that for all practical purpose it explains that he was Polish;P

Piłsudski is a Polish coat of arms.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 1, 10, 01:10    #44
Sokrates:
Sorry? You're bringing wikipedia and given your outlandish thesis that Kraków had a German minority i'm inclined to believe you either edited it or are aware that its bollocks, find another source.

Where are your sources?
Oh and I didn't say they were a minority...in Krakau's golden age they were the MAJORITY!

Here yet another source:
http://www.archive.org/stream/cracowroyalcapit00lepsuoft/cracowroyalca pit00lepsuoft_djvu.txt

Quotes:

.....
IN the vast plains of Little Poland, now laid waste by the
first Mongolian invasion, the whole civilization of the
country was annihilated, the soil left fallow, the cities
burnt down and depopulated.

The only means to raise the
country economically was the introduction of foreign capital and
foreign hands for work. German colonization, on a large scale,
was begun


etc....tire yourself out!

I'm done discussing with you as long your part consists only of abuse and far fetched opinions without any links to support it!
McCoyThreads: 46
Posts: 1,755
Joined: Jul 3, 08
 Feb 1, 10, 05:05    #45
jasinski:
Is Józef Piłsudski the king of modern Poles?

yes
SokratesThreads: 19
Posts: 4,464
Joined: Jan 19, 09
[Suspended]
 Feb 1, 10, 06:02    #46
Bratwurst Boy:
Oh and I didn't say they were a minority...in Krakau's golden age they were the MAJORITY!

Yes and you lied, your only proof was wiki, just like last time, given that anyone including you can edit it and we've had examples of people doing just that to fit their argument yours is worthless.

Bratwurst Boy:
http://www.archive.org/stream/cracowroyalcapit00lepsuoft/cracowr oyalca pit00lepsuoft_djvu.txt

Where does it say they were anything but a minority in Kraków? Your source only states the facts, Germans were invited to Poland where over 200 years they polonised, nowhere does it say they were a majority in Kraków (since they werent).

Produce a source that you couldnt write yourself, any source and we'll have a discussion, thus far you're basing it off something that anyone could write.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 1, 10, 06:13    #47
Sokrates:
Yes and you lied, your only proof was wiki, just like last time, given that anyone including you can edit it and we've had examples of people doing just that to fit their argument yours is worthless.

Where did I lie you arsehole?

Again in plain, easy words (you can find it in any work about Krakau):

The city was almost entirely destroyed during the Mongol invasions of 1241, 1259 and 1287

It was rebuilt and incorporated in 1257, based on the Magdeburg law, with tax benefits and trade privileges for its citizens.[10] These citizens were German settlers who moved in during the Ostsiedlung, and who constituted a majority of burghers in contemporary Polish and Bohemian towns.[11]

As the capital of a powerful state and a member of the Hanseatic League, the city attracted many craftsmen, businesses, and guilds as science and the arts began to flourish.[15]

Germans constituted the majority during the 14th century, and became Polonized in the 16th century.[13]

14th century
In 1308 the rebellion of German speaking citizens of Kraków is broken by the Polish King. That costs Poland Gdansk annexed by Teutonic Orders. German speaking citizens will no more have political ambitions. They learn Polish and try to Polonize as quickly as possible.

Golden Age ends!

These are the facts arsehole...you can find them everywhere!

Here the same:

http://www.knowledgerush.com/kr/encyclopedia/Cracow,_Poland/
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 1, 10, 06:31    #48
The first polish book was printed in Krakau by a German!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_printing_in_Poland

The oldest known print from Poland is considered to be the Almanach cracoviense ad annum 1474 (Cracovian Almanac for the Year 1474)[2] which is a single-sheet astronomical wall calendar for the year 1474 printed and published in 1473 [3] by Kasper Straube.

....
The first print written in Polish language is believed to be Hortulus Animae polonice, a Polish version of Hortulus Animae written by Biernat of Lublin, printed and published in 1513 by Florian Ungler in Kraków.

Do you really believe Veit Stoss and those printers were in Krakau just accidentally?

How do you think a town becomes a member of the german Hanseatic League in the first place??
It was a german merchant union after all!

Better you bring something or shut your trap!

Here another link who also tells the same story:

http://www.1911encyclopedia.org/Cracow

The city was practically ruined during the first Tatar invasion in 1241, but the introduction of German colonists restored its prosperity, and in 1257 it received "Magdeburg rights," i.e. a civic constitution modelled on that of Magdeburg.
In this year the Tuchhalle was built.


Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 1, 10, 07:14    #49
Another link with the same informations:

http://www.google.com/search?q=Krakow+history+Germans&hl=en&safe=off&t bo=p&num=100&newwindow=1&ei=X3BmS-rpIcOH_AaU54XsAw&sa=X&oi=timeline_ot her_dates&ct=timeline-other-dates&ved=0CNUDEKUC&tbs=tl:1,tlul:1200,tlu h:2010

....
Crakow was also the cultural capital of the country with a university founded in 1364. In the 15 th century, Krakow's intellectuals ...The cities, long populated by foreigners--mostly Germans--slowly became more Polish.
The best example of this is the capital of Krakow, where by the end of the 15 th century the Polish element had become a majority.

meaning

Germans constituted the majority during the 14th century, and became Polonized in the 16th century.[13]

Who is here the liar, arsehole!
vetalaThreads: -
Posts: 512
Joined: Jul 10, 09
Edited by: vetala  Feb 1, 10, 14:23    #50
BB, what exactly are you trying to prove? In 16th century they were 'polonized' and not by force so technically they are included in our ancestry. Yes, the input of our German ancestors was quite invaluable xD
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 1, 10, 14:38    #51
vetala:
....so technically they are included in our ancestry. Yes, the input of our German ancestors was quite invaluable xD

Yes, that was it....thank you! Now I can rest in peace :)
IronsideThreads: 56
Posts: 6,196
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 Feb 1, 10, 23:54    #52
Sokrates:
Piłsudski is a Polish coat of arms.

do you know why?
NathanThreads: 33
Posts: 1,846
Joined: Feb 13, 09
 Feb 3, 10, 05:21    #53
Sokrates:
i'm inclined to believe you either edited it

Everyone edits for you?! Don't incline, pajaca kawałek ;)
Mr GrunwaldThreads: 34
Posts: 2,354
Joined: Dec 16, 08
Edited by: Mr Grunwald  Feb 3, 10, 06:57    #54
Bratwurst Boy:
Veit Stoß a clearly German artists who did alot of cool work for now-polish towns but still is and was a German. ;)

Even if in-fact he was, he was still accepted as a Pole from the Polish community for all work he had done for Poles.
And Germans called him a Pole when he went back to Germany...

It's not a fact to call someone a Pole it's an honor!
If you look back in history there were no Poles 1000 years ago, there were Lędzianie, Mazowszanie etc

It's the connection of tribes wich made them all Polish (the cause itself, the joint to survive together) and anyone wanting to join it, can call himself a Pole if he truely feels like one in spirit. Piłsudski saw on himself as Pole/Lithuanian, Lithuanian body with a Polish soul. That's why the Lithuanians don't like him. He refused to acknowledge anything like separational Lithuania.

A true I RP thinker

BB
look at www.commonwealth.pl and check up the "Deutsche Vita" the choir music is wonderful (the best ive ever heard)

and yes Piłsudski is going to be Poland's king of all time! :D
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Feb 3, 10, 07:54    #55
Thanks for the link Gruni! :)
BorrkaThreads: 49
Posts: 769
Joined: Apr 25, 08
 Feb 4, 10, 10:51    #56
Bratwurst Boy:
Golden Age ends!

No, it just starts.

It's a ground school's level basic knowledge that so called golden age of Cracow and in general of the Polish Commonwealth took place in 15th/16th century, driven by Polish magnates and their money.
It's rather interesting that all this happened first after full polonisation of the German element. Probably every culture needs its national background and hired craftsmen from the overpopulated and hunger striven Reich were not enough to do the job.
With all respect to Veit Stoss ... but who paid him and decided about character of his work ?

But you are obviously overestimating those German influences. After the first quasi prehistoric period of German presence Cracow became more and more Polish with a lot of Italian color.
Same goes for the influence of the Baltic oriented German Hansa.
Cracow used to be a member of it but you better take a look at any map LOL.

Anyway, nice remake of uncle Adolf's good nite fairy tales for Hitlerjugend!
vetalaThreads: -
Posts: 512
Joined: Jul 10, 09
 Feb 4, 10, 12:39    #57
Don't be hatin' Borrka ;) I'm sure your opinion would be the same as BB's if the discussion was about Polish influence in Lithuanian/Ukrainian/whicheverelse cities.
Mr GrunwaldThreads: 34
Posts: 2,354
Joined: Dec 16, 08
Edited by: Mr Grunwald  Feb 4, 10, 22:08    #58
Bratwurst Boy:
Thanks for the link Gruni! :)

No problem (Kein problem)

Borrka:
It's rather interesting that all this happened first after full polonisation of the German element.

Still the German element was there, it's the mixing itself with a lot of cultures which made the Polish culture so unique at that time.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Feb 4, 10, 22:47    #59
Borrka:
But you are obviously overestimating those German influences. After the first quasi prehistoric period of German presence Cracow became more and more Polish with a lot of Italian color

You call history back till the 16th century pre-historic??? Interesting.... :)

Borrka:
It's rather interesting that all this happened first after full polonisation of the German element.

Nope, all these german artists and merchants which made the towns so beautiful and prosperous were most successful till their polonization.
And the polonization is synchronous with the end of Polands Golden Age...coincidence?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krakow#Golden_age

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_in_Poland
TITThreads: 9
Posts: 353
Joined: Jan 7, 10
Edited by: TIT  Feb 4, 10, 22:53    #60
just before partitions there was unbelievable amount of Germans who became Poles
just like the ones who are descendants of later ( XIX ) wave who bravely fought Nazi Germany in Polish ranks

page 2 of 4:  « Prev  1  2  3  4  Next »

Home / History of Poland / Unanswered [this forum] | Similar


Similar discussions:

Reply re: Is Józef Piłsudski the king of modern Poles?

If you're reading this, you are probably not a registered user yet and cannot access all forums and features!

 - Before creating a new thread, make sure to follow the Thread Title Creation Rules.
 - Your message must comply with the General Forum Rules.
 - If you have further questions, check the Forum FAQ & Feedback section.

To post anonymously, please enter a temporary and unique username (without password) or login and post as a member.

Username:   Password: 



re: Is Józef Piłsudski the king of modern Poles?


Posting Guidelines:

- Stay on topic. If your post is not related to this thread, create a new thread or post in the Off-topic forum.
- Use the Search and Similar Threads features to avoid duplicating threads.
- Do not insult or harass others, play nicely!
- Do not personally attack others to avoid temporary or permanent suspension.

Is There A Polish Foreign Legion?  General Anders and one of the biggest "What Ifs?" of WW2


Random: Rented car from Germany to Poland



Home | Unanswered | Archives | Random | Statistics Time in Poland: 00:02 / Feb 10

About Us | Contact Us | Rules, Privacy | Poland Advertising

© 2005-12 PolishForums.com