The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Home / History  % width posts: 42

Poles as Iroquois of Europe


shewolf 5 | 1,077
16 Jun 2010 #31
What year did he say this?
OP Ironside 53 | 12,407
16 Jun 2010 #32
in the year of the rat!
Borrka 37 | 593
17 Jun 2010 #33
Quite easy to understand idolizing Bismarck in ex-GDR with 30% of its population living on the dole or at least using the "social safety net" - no doubt about his main role in creating the first welfare state worldwide.

On the contrary, his political "achievements" were just paving the way for Adolf and his cronies.
I suggest watch the German movie Das Weisse Band (White Ribbon) - it's all about Bismarck's proto-Nazi Germany.
youtube.com/watch?v=2aaapMYGBJs
hague1cmaeron 14 | 1,368
17 Jun 2010 #34
unrivaled education system

I don't think so, Poland had an education ministry before Prussia!
OP Ironside 53 | 12,407
17 Jun 2010 #35
May become touristic attraction

they may!
Bratwurst Boy 12 | 11,824
17 Jun 2010 #36
no doubt about his main role in creating the first welfare state worldwide.

Not only Bismarck himself build and ruled a highly competetive and successful country, after WWII it was the new western Bundesrepublik who decided for a social capitalism aka Bismarck (not the commie GDR just for your information).

This model proved to be one of the most successful models for more than 60 years, not only in Europe but in the world! The basics of Germany's political peace and economical successes.

I suggest watch the German movie Das Weisse Band (White Ribbon) - it's all about Bismarck's proto-Nazi Germany.

You are spouting crap again!
Nothing surprising here...and again you get your facts wrong.
The "Das weiße Band" was about the time before WWI. The only one from this village soon going out to kill for Kaiser and Fatherland was the narrator, the "good" teacher. Should tell you something...if you would have a braincell left in your easy peasy black/white world of thinking!
Borrka 37 | 593
19 Jun 2010 #37
(not the commie GDR just for your information).

It's a common knowledge in my "black/white world" that commie GDR was a total failure - now it has changed to a permanent burden for the Western tax payer .

The "Das weiße Band" was about the time before WWI.

<Die dänische Zeitung Politiken sieht in dem Film ein "Zurückkehren zu Hanekes Wurzeln der deutschen Sprache und Kulturtradition." Das weiße Band sei "ein erzdeutscher Film über die Deutschheit.">

<Daniel Kothenschulte nannte den Film in der Frankfurter Rundschau ironisierend ein Lehrstück, das sich "früh zu erkennen" gibt: "Zwei Jahrzehnte später wären diese bösen Kinder erwachsene Nazis" und bemängelt die Holzschnittartigkeit der wenigen Figuren, spricht aber dennoch von "faszinierenden zweieinhalb Stunden".>

de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_weiße_Band_-_Eine_deutsche_Kindergeschichte
Bratwurst Boy 12 | 11,824
19 Jun 2010 #38
Zurückkehren zu Hanekes Wurzeln der deutschen Sprache und Kulturtradition.

And I like that very much too! Enough of Hollywood...

Das weiße Band sei "ein erzdeutscher Film über die Deutschheit.">

Well, that might be even true...:)
I liked what I saw (not all of it tough)...very homely...the life of my great/grandparents.
Not unusual for most farmer villages of that time across Europe one would think.

<Daniel Kothenschulte nannte den Film in der Frankfurter Rundschau ironisierend ein Lehrstück, das sich "früh zu erkennen" gibt: "Zwei Jahrzehnte später wären diese bösen Kinder erwachsene Nazis" und bemängelt die Holzschnittartigkeit der wenigen Figuren, spricht aber dennoch von "faszinierenden zweieinhalb Stunden".>

But that is an opinion, nothing else, just one interpretation.
There are interviews with Haneke about this...there is nothing of that kind about this movie.
All opinions and when you think about who was going to go to war soon actually all things get another perspective.

You know, there are these guys and gals who will see Nazis everywhere...you are one of them!
Get a grip!
Borrka 37 | 593
19 Jun 2010 #39
Not really.
I'm rather aware that nazi-tmes in Alemania are over.
"Deutschtümmelei" is still alive !
Bratwurst Boy 12 | 11,824
19 Jun 2010 #40
What's wrong with "Deutschtümelei"? What about "Polandtümelei" ;)

Sorry to disappoint, it's very well alive and even growing, better get used to it!

PS: When you really believe that the Nazi times in Alemania are over maybe you can work now on your habit to bring in the Nazis in every discussion...be it Bismarck or an innocent movie?

But even if not, the Nazis are only an outlet for your Germanophobia anyhow...if it weren't the Nazis it would be something else so I expect not really anything from you. I just don't care a rats fart about your opinion about my Fatherland!

Have a nice day! :) Oh and here another one for the go:
Borrka 37 | 593
19 Jun 2010 #41
What about "Polandtümelei" ;)

Just start a new thread lol.
Holy_Winged_Hussar
10 Aug 2022 #42
@Bratwurst Boy
How's being a toxic nationalist going? You joined the far-right yet ;)


Home / History / Poles as Iroquois of Europe
BoldItalic [quote]
 
To post as Guest, enter a temporary username or login and post as a member.