PolishForums.com
POLAND . The Unofficial Guide
Unanswered | Archives
Meet Polish People at PF! Witamy, Guest | PF Members | Gold Members

Polish Forums / News, Politics /

Achievements of the Tusk's government.


page 9 of 12:  « Prev  1  ...  8  9  10  11  12  Next » posts: 333

THE HITMANThreads: 1
Posts: 416
Joined: Jun 15, 10
 Pictures: 1
 May 18, 11, 23:26    #241
delphiandomine:
Funny thing is - you're making the usual PiS mistake of assuming that anyone who opposes you is automatically a PO voter.

Where did you dream that statement from ? I think you,re losing it too. Now you,re playing to an audience (
delphiandomine:
we enjoy showing the world
)
Just showed what a right pair of wallies you are. Get a life !

delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 May 19, 11, 11:44    #242
Another success of the Tusk government -

http://thenews.pl/1/12/Artykul/24842,Wages-grow-faster-than-inflation- show-new-stats

Of course, the usual suspects will accuse GUS of lying.
frdThreads: 8
Posts: 1,956
Joined: Feb 3, 09
 May 19, 11, 14:41    #243
delphiandomine:
or a renewed PiS (without the Kaczynski maniacs) will win.

I'd say a PIS comeback would be possible, if some kind of a big disaster hit Poland. That's the only chance for Kaczynski to get more votes, by preying on people who are in distress. And any gov that raigns during the time of distress is automatically getting a thumb down from the hoi polloi.
Grzegorz_Threads: 81
Posts: 6,213
Joined: Nov 16, 06
 May 19, 11, 21:29    #244
pawian:
The first that comes to my mind: 3 years ago Russia lifted the embargo on Polish products like meat, fruit and vegetables introduced in 2005 during PiS regime`s rule. Also, Russia started cooperation over Katyn Massacre, e.g., by opening the Soviet archives.

pawian:
But I am losing time because you are going to turn it down as worthless, aren`t you? :):):)


I wouldn't call It worthless, rather... extremely minimalistic... Anyway, I didn't really start this thread to discuss If something is worthless or not, I didn't bring up PiS etc. here, I am genuinely interested what are the achievements of this government according to PO voters. I find it fascinating that so far no polical party has won the elections twice in a row (some totally collapsed like AWS or SLD) but PO is still leading after almost 4 years despite being the worst of them.

pawian:

Yes, provide me with respected links where I can read what you said: Poland is heavily criticized by EU for huge deficit and lack of reforms. The ratings are under huge pressure. :):):):)


OK :):):):)

http://www.wbj.pl/article-50087-polands-credit-rating-could-be-under-h uge-pressure-says-fitch.html?typ=ise

http://www.polishmarket.com/73566/Ecofin-puts-Poland-under-excessive-d eficit-procedure.shtml

http://www.jltgroup.com/risk-and-insurance/news/poland-struggles-cope- economic-crisis-estimated-external-bills-1-billion-dollars/

http://www.warsawvoice.pl/WVpage/pages/article.php/16331/news

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-04-26/poland-s-budget-deficit-widen ed-to-7-9-of-gdp-last-year-debt-rose-to-55-.html

http://www.warsawvoice.pl/WVpage/pages/article.php/16700/news

pawian:

I see you have started to learn.

In January you commited this thread:
Poland is going bankrupt

Not bad. Keep up good work.


I feel sorry for you If you really don't understand the difference between economic growth and the situation of public finances.

delphiandomine:

In general, Tusk's achievement has been to promote Poland as an island of stability - a kind of Germany-lite if you will. You can see this from the endless foreign commentaries about Poland - the country is seen as stable and somewhat reliable. That has helped Poland no end


How did that help Poland ?

delphiandomine:
I noticed recently that the rates for a decent, reliable physical worker are going through the roof.


Yep, something like 7-10 PLN/h.

delphiandomine:

Uh, the current Government is actually doing quite a good job of it.


Of what ? In case of corruption or conditions for business we are behind many African countries and nothing has been improved.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 May 19, 11, 22:23    #245
Grzegorz_:
I find it fascinating that so far no polical party has won the elections twice in a row (some totally collapsed like AWS or SLD) but PO is still leading after almost 4 years despite being the worst of them.


They can't be the worst if they're on course to be the first Government to be re-elected, can they?

Grzegorz_:
How did that help Poland ?


By encouraging people not to run away with the capital the second the crisis hit. Look at what happened in Latvia, Ukraine, Greece, etc - investors got scared. Poland managed to stay stable throughout all of it - and enjoyed the confidence of investors as a result.

Grzegorz_:
Yep, something like 7-10 PLN/h.


You must be kidding. Perhaps to get someone who likes drinking during work and so on, but to get a reliable physical worker who doesn't drink/slack off, you're looking at almost double that in the cities.

Grzegorz_:
Of what ? In case of corruption or conditions for business we are behind many African countries and nothing has been improved.


Behind many African countries? Care to name some?
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
 May 20, 11, 13:03    #246
Grzegorz_:
How did that help Poland ?


Stop asking silly questions. You are not your boss who interrogates you about your performance at work.


Grzegorz_:
I wouldn't call It worthless, rather... extremely minimalistic...


Wow. Certainly, it is a great progress.

Grzegorz_:
Of what ? In case of corruption or conditions for business we are behind many African countries and nothing has been improved.


100 years behind negroes was a slogan used in communist Poland. It seems you are still stuck in those times.
VarsovianThreads: 91
Posts: 568
Joined: Nov 23, 06
 May 20, 11, 15:45    #247
Why are there 9 pages on Tusk's achievements? Seems excessive :)
z_dariusThreads: 22
Posts: 5,091
Joined: Oct 18, 07
 May 20, 11, 15:53    #248
delphiandomine:
Grzegorz_:
Of what ? In case of corruption or conditions for business we are behind many African countries and nothing has been improved.


Behind many African countries? Care to name some?

I guess it will depend on what "many" means:

32 Botswana
43 Tunisia
46 South Africa
47 Namibia
70 Egypt
70 Poland
70 Burkina Faso
70 Syria
70 Lesotho
VarsovianThreads: 91
Posts: 568
Joined: Nov 23, 06
 May 20, 11, 16:53    #249
Point of information:
Burkina Faso means "Land of Incorruptible Souls" - everything else is up for sale
z_dariusThreads: 22
Posts: 5,091
Joined: Oct 18, 07
 May 20, 11, 16:55    #250
Varsovian:
Burkina Faso means "Land of Incorruptible Souls" - everything else is up for sale

ddidn't know that
juicy
Grzegorz_Threads: 81
Posts: 6,213
Joined: Nov 16, 06
 May 22, 11, 22:26    #251
delphiandomine:
They can't be the worst if they're on course to be the first Government to be re-elected, can they?


You seem to believe that democracy is a kind of perfect market. When a political party is re-elected It must by good by definition then. I think you could find many examples of bad government being elected or re-elected around the world.

delphiandomine:
Look at what happened in Latvia, Ukraine, Greece, etc - investors got scared.


All of these countries had huge structural problems before the crisis, when Poland had healthy growth. Besides, Poland went down from +5-7% before the crisis to + 1-3% during the crisis, not that much different than from +2-3% to -2-3%, which was typical for EU countries.

delphiandomine:
You must be kidding.


No, I don't. You say that physical workers make 3500-4000 a month "in the cities" ?

delphiandomine:

Behind many African countries? Care to name some?


z_darius did that, I agree with him that It depends on what one means by "many" but there use to be at least a few of them in such rankings, what's more important is Poland's position among EU member states. Usually It's either the lasty one or a few places ahead of Bulgaria or Romania. The bottom line is, Poland is no a total shi*t hole not thanks to the government but despite the government.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 May 22, 11, 22:51    #252
Grzegorz_:
You seem to believe that democracy is a kind of perfect market. When a political party is re-elected It must by good by definition then. I think you could find many examples of bad government being elected or re-elected around the world.


Bad governments tend to get kicked out. Good governments tend to get re-elected.

That's how it works in most developed countries. Poland is no exception.

Grzegorz_:
what's more important is Poland's position among EU member states. Usually It's either the lasty one or a few places ahead of Bulgaria or Romania. The bottom line is, Poland is no a total shi*t hole not thanks to the government but despite the government.


Poland is pretty much equal with the rest of the EU-8 countries, except Slovenia - and that's because Slovenia started from a much better position with no debts, along with being smaller and therefore easier to manage. The 7 countries I'm referring to (Estonia, Slovakia, Czech Republic, Hungary, Lithuania, Latvia and Poland) are all catching up rapidly with Greece and Portugal - so Poland is doing just fine.
Grzegorz_Threads: 81
Posts: 6,213
Joined: Nov 16, 06
 May 23, 11, 19:51    #253
delphiandomine:

Bad governments tend to get kicked out. Good governments tend to get re-elected.


Do you think that Berlusconi's government is a good one ?

delphiandomine:
That's how it works in most developed countries. Poland is no exception.


Poland is hardly a developed country.

delphiandomine:
Poland is pretty much equal with the rest of the EU-8 countries, except Slovenia


You still don't get it (or rather pretend not to get it) It's not about overall economic situation but about conditions for business, which are determinated mainly by the governing politicians. Polish business hasn't collapsed yet, despite haveing to operate under terrible conditions, yes... and that proves what... ?
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
Edited by: pawian  May 11, 12, 22:18    #254
Despite trade union`s rage and opposition (right wing PiS and left wing SLD) protests,


MPs have voted to adopt amendments to the pension system in Poland, raising the retirement age for men and women, gradually from 2013, to 67 years of age.

http://www.thenews.pl/1/12/Artykul/99029,MPs-vote-for-controversial-bi ll-to-raise-retirement-age

It is definitely a great success of the government.

Late retirement is standard in Europe today.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 May 11, 12, 23:25    #255
pawian:
It is definitely a great success of the government.

Late retirement is standard in Europe today.

A Great success ? Why don't they ship all people to slavery and than sell the land, that would be even greater success, and think about monies you and your cronies could make on that 1
Sure, late retirement is standard in Europe eh? Where exactly ?
What about jobs for those old people ? What if they cannot get any job?
Also minimum wages are higher in Europe like four, six times, Why government is not focusing on align to those standards eh?

Maybe because they have no monies and they are desperately trying to find dosh anywhere !
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
 May 11, 12, 23:45    #256
Ironside:
A Great success ?


Yes, it is a success of Tusk`s government. And your nonsensical rants can`t change it. :):):):)

Goodnight, Iron. :):):)

Your silly answers always help me realise I am spending too much time in the forum .:):):):)

Thank you for that. :):):):)
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
Edited by: pawian  May 12, 12, 20:07    #257
pawian:
Goodnight, Iron. :):):)


Ok, after a good night`s sleep and a few zlotys earned at Saturday courses, I feel like King Kong.

Iron, I am ready for you!


Ironside:
Why don't they ship all people to slavery and than sell the land,


Silly.

Ironside:
Sure, late retirement is standard in Europe eh? Where exactly ?


E.g., Germany, Norway - 67.

UK, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Belgium etc etc - 65.

Ironside:
What about jobs for those old people ?


What about pensions for early pensioners? What if the state won`t be able to finance it like now?

You have no idea about the pension system in Poland. E.g., in the old system, a policeman was entitled to retire after 15 years. Funny, wasn`t it?


Read this article from 2006. It shows how serious the problem was and still is.
http://www.wbj.pl/article-32130-bringing-zus-back-to-earth.html

Youthful retirees
With 1.5 million people in early retirement, Poland has the youngest old-age pensioners in the world, and they cost the budget zł.20 billion annually. In 2005, the average man beginning his retirement was 58.7 years old. For women starting their retirement, the average age was 56. According to the projections of the Central Statistical Office, in 2030 people older than 65 will account for 24 percent of society. Currently, the figure is 13 percent.
Someone has to pay into the system in order for retirees to receive their pensions, but the number of those professionally active in Poland continues to shrink. However, instead of finding new ways of putting more people to work, subsequent governments have given in to the demands of various groups of workers, granting them new retirement privileges.
"Miners can opt for early retirement schemes, and as a result they actually get three times more from the social-security system than they put into it while they were still professionally active. Their annual contributions amount to zł.3 billion and they obtain zł.8 billion. I don't question anyone's right to the old-age pension when they reach the right age, but if governments don't change their policy, we risk a breakdown of public finance," warns Mordasewicz.


"I believe that the issue of social insurance is the most urgent problem for the government to solve. With adverse demographic tendencies and more and more groups demanding privileges, the state will finally go bankrupt," Mordasewicz warns.
Robert Gwiazdowski is blunt about the issue: "Since the times of Bismarck, states had difficulties in dealing with these issues. Some cope better, some worse. People have to stop taking for granted the fact that the state is going to support them in their old age and realize that by going on strike and demanding early retirement schemes they actually do it against their children. Finally, people simply have to have more children."



Let`s be frank, experts say the new reform is a very mild one because it is going to prolong the changes for many years.

The government wants to gradually raise the retirement age starting from 2013. Every four months the retirement age will be rise by one month (in other words, rising by a total of three months every year). In this way the target retirement age of 67 will be reached by 2020 for men, and 2040 for women. The Prime Minister emphasises that the reform is to safeguard public finances.


Ironside:
Also minimum wages are higher in Europe like four, six times, Why government is not focusing on align to those standards eh?


Because the efficiency of Polish workers is still lower than in Western Europe. We lose too much time at work. However, wages are higher in the old EU but the cost of living too. Don`t forget it.

Now, I expect rational arguments from you.

Are you able to provide them?

I doubt that.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 May 14, 12, 01:27    #258
pawian:
Silly.

billy ?
pawian:
E.g., Germany, Norway - 67.

Norway correct !
Although I must add that in the western countries average life expectancy for males is about 8 years higher. In practical terms it means that average male Polish pensioner can enjoy his retainment for about 4 years while his Norwegian counterpart about 12 years. I would say that is the substantial difference.
Germany ? wrong!
That is typical sloppiness of PO so called experts !!!!!!:(
Currently retainment age in Germany is 65, however starting this year retainment age will be gradually growing for a month (for 12 years) and then two months for another six years. So, in the year 2029 retainment age in Germany will be 67.

pawian:
UK, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Belgium etc etc - 65.

Again Sweden - 61, although law allows to work those who want till 67, freely chosen !!!Also policemen and fireman can retire at the age of 58!
What do you mean ect ????
Other countries in Europe;
Finland - 63 !
France - 60 (will rise in 2018 to 62!)
Italy - 57 in 2014 will be 62!
Czech - 60!
Hungary - 62
Lithuania - 62
EC has given some recommendation as to increase of minimum retainment age but one again Tusk bunch of thieves and greedy morons goes to use it as a pretext to rob the nation some more.
As it was with VAT, then with payments for few unfinished highways and now with a new retainment age.
Coffers must be empty, four years era of orgy and blind robbery come to an end.
It is desperate move, that new "reform" gives government about billion zloty per year.
They are desperate indeed !
pawian:
Because the efficiency of Polish workers is still lower than in Western Europe

Because managers are shity and their efficiency is low.
pawian:
However, wages are higher in the old EU but the cost of living too. Don`t forget it.

slightly, I would say that wages are about five times higher in the old EU than Poland whereas cost of living is about twice as much.
pawian:
Now, I expect rational arguments from you.

Back to old tricks pawain ? It was you not me who lost
rational arguments

debate
and it is you not me who should be worrying about his credibility !
I'm not saying that pension system in Poland is perfect.I think it should be changed long time ago. Unfortunately there were nobody able to do it and what is presented by the Tusk government is not any reform either but primitive and simple attempt at saving some money for gov budged!At the expense of hard working senior citizens.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 May 14, 12, 03:11    #259
Another factor I forgot to mention but quite obvious - where all those people will be working ?eh?
You do not expect 66 years old zipping up and down scaffolding ? or digging coal at the fore ?
eh?
jon357Threads: -
Posts: 621
Joined: Mar 15, 12
 Pictures: 1
 May 14, 12, 03:39    #260
Ironside:
Another factor I forgot to mention but quite obvious - where all those people will be working ?eh?
You do not expect 66 years old zipping up and down scaffolding ? or digging coal at the fore ?
eh?

There are always jobs to suit and given that the increase in retirement age is partly due to more and more people staying fit and healthy for longer, we shouldn't make assumptions. Anyway, nobody here is expected to perform a task at work that they are unfit for.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 May 14, 12, 13:26    #261
jon357:
There are always jobs to suit

Really ? In Poland ?
Are those jobs paid ?or we are making assumptions here ?
jon357Threads: -
Posts: 621
Joined: Mar 15, 12
 Pictures: 1
 May 14, 12, 15:01    #262
That's just nit-picking. There's an aging population, life expectancy is increasing and there's a finite pot of money for social provision. The current government are working with the same situation that any other party would - except PiS would simply duck the issue or make promises that they could never fulfil. Or hope that prayer would solve the problem.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
Edited by: Ironside  May 14, 12, 15:14    #263
jon357:
. The current government are working with the same situation that any other party would - except PiS would simply duck the issue or make promises that they could never fulfil. Or hope that prayer would solve the problem.

Assumption ?
jon357:
That's just nit-picking.


For you ! For an 66 years old man with health problems and without substantial savings that is a real life and death issue.
jon357Threads: -
Posts: 621
Joined: Mar 15, 12
 Pictures: 1
 May 14, 12, 16:37    #264
And the issue is that if he has what you describe as health problems then he is in any case unfit tor work. If he is fit for work, then being 66 is no longer a reason for the state to retire him on full pension.

Unless you know of some magic source of money.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 May 14, 12, 19:21    #265
jon357:
And the issue is that if he has what you describe as health problems then he is in any case unfit tor work. If he is fit for work, then being 66 is no longer a reason for the state to retire him on full pension.

Fit or not what kind of job could possibly find manual laborer at the age 66 or even 64. In Poland where average life expectancy for males is about 71?
Do you think that an average 66 years old do not have some underlaying health issue which would impair his ability to compete with 30 years old ?
Ask any physician.
jon357:
Unless you know of some magic source of money.

a good printer ?
jon357Threads: -
Posts: 621
Joined: Mar 15, 12
 Pictures: 1
 May 14, 12, 19:57    #266
What makes you think that a. he'd be doing the same thing or that b. the government haven't thought about that? They aren't PiS, so they do actually think!
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
Edited by: pawian  May 14, 12, 20:30    #267
Ironside:
Again Sweden - 61, although law allows to work those who want till 67, freely chosen !!!



Interesting that you provide such data while I provide this:


It is not a pure coincidence that the economies of Sweden, Norway and Denmark are in better shape than those of Greece, Italy, Spain and Portugal. The big difference in retirement age plays a big role. Sweden’s statutory retirement age is 65 and the actual exit age, which is lower due to various early retirement schemes, is 64.3 according to Eurostat’s most recent figures. That is the highest in the EU.

From an article August 2011
http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/business-tech/debt-crisis/1108 15/europe-debt-crisis-retirement-age



So, who is wrong?



That is not all.

Earlier this year, Sweden launched a commission to study retirement. “As the life expectancy increases, more people need to work longer than today. Too many leave before turning 65. This is about increasing the actual exit age,” said Sweden’s Secretary of Social Insurances, Ulf Kristersson. The commission will consider limiting early retirement schemes, raising the age that workers are entitled to keep their jobs from 67 to 69, and further raising the statutory age of retirement. “More people need to work longer than today or the pensions will decrease,” Kristersson said.



Iron, I have bad news for you:


In the last two years, several EU members have had no choice but to raise the retirement age. Germany raised the retirement age from 65 to 67, Ireland and United Kingdom plan to raise it from 65 to 66, and Spain from 65 to 67. When Greece promised austerity in return for its bailout, Greek social affairs minister Andreas Loverdos said that the average actual retirement age would be raised from 53 to 67. “This is about saving the country from collapse,” he told the Financial Times.



Ironside:
Italy - 57 in 2014 will be 62!



The Berlusconi administration used a sophisticated method to raise the retirement age from 65 to 68.5 years by 2050 by adjusting it gradually according to life expectancy projections. The first adjustment will occur in 2015, the second in 2019 and subsequent adjustments every 3 years thereafter, saving the government more than $100 billion.
[/i]

But the Polish reform will also be introduced for many years. Did you read it al all?:

The government wants to gradually raise the retirement age starting from 2013. Every four months the retirement age will be rise by one month (in other words, rising by a total of three months every year). In this way the target retirement age of 67 will be reached by 2020 for men, and 2040 for women.

IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,786
Joined: Feb 26, 09
Edited by: Ironside  May 14, 12, 21:09    #268
pawian:
From an article August 2011
http://www.globalpost.com/dispatch/news/busi

that is some political website of Micheal Goldfarb ....phew!?
pawian:
Iron, I have bad news for you:

have you read my post ?
I have provided correct data while you provided incorrect and then you trying to salvage your loses by quoting some odd website !
Why are you debating with yourself ?You have given your arguments why such change in Poland is needed now and why it should be done in this way and I have responded !
Please respond to my original post, otherwise our chat makes no sense !

quote=jon357]What makes you think that a. he'd be doing the same thing or that b. the government haven't thought about that? They aren't PiS, so they do actually think[/quote]
do they ? the question remains about what ?because hey are not doing that well governing that country !
What makes me think that haven't thought about that ?Like missing promised motorways, like the way they handled the Smolensk crash .....
pawianThreads: 90
Posts: 5,397
Joined: May 30, 08
 Pictures: 2
Edited by: pawian  May 14, 12, 21:41    #269
Ironside:
that is some political website of Micheal Goldfarb ....phew!?


And?

If you want another source on Sweden, here you are - a Swedish site in English:

http://www.thelocal.se/31922/20110208/


Ironside:
I have provided correct data


Nope, you didn`t. Your info on Sweden was false.

And you also abstained from providing any links to your sources.

On top of that all, you are constantly lying.

Bad Iron.
HipisThreads: -
Posts: 217
Joined: Apr 3, 12
 May 14, 12, 23:37    #270
I see the nuances of political debate a la PO-PiS have reached Polish Forums :D


page 9 of 12:  « Prev  1  ...  8  9  10  11  12  Next »

Home / News, Politics / Unanswered [this forum] | Similar


Similar discussions:

EU tribunal overrules Polish name contest in Lithuania  Row over status of Poles in Germany sours relations


Random: Where did a post go?

Only registered and logged-in users may post here. Please log in or register.


42 [Guests - 29 / Members - 13] users on live forums now


Home | Unanswered | Archives | Random | Statistics Time in Poland: 19:59 / May 26

About Us | Contact Us | Rules, Privacy | Poland Advertising

© 2005-12 PolishForums.com