PolishForums.com
POLAND . The Unofficial Guide
Unanswered | Archives
Poland Now and Then Witamy, Guest | PF Members | Gold Members

Polish Forums / News, Politics /

Friedrich Nietzsche - Polish or German ?


page 1 of 3:  1  2  3  Next » posts: 75

JulekcgThreads: 1
Posts: 36
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Administrator  Oct 17, 08, 06:20    #1
Lukasz, you will be banned again if you register another account.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Nietzsche

Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche (October 15, 1844 – August 25, 1900) (German pronunciation: [ˈfʁiːdʁɪç ˈvɪlhəlm ˈniːtʃə]) was a nineteenth-century German philosopher and classical philologist. He wrote critical texts on religion, morality, contemporary culture, philosophy, and science, using a distinctive German language style and displaying a fondness for metaphor and aphorism. Nietzsche's influence remains substantial within and beyond philosophy, notably in existentialism and postmodernism.



Born on October 15, 1844, Nietzsche grew up in the small town of Röcken, near Leipzig, in the Prussian Province of Saxony.


Nietzschean ideas exercised a major influence on several prominent European philosophers, including Michel Foucault, Gilles Deleuze, Jacques Derrida, Martin Heidegger, Albert Camus, and Jean-Paul Sartre. In the Anglo-American tradition, the scholarship of Walter Kaufmann and R. J. Hollingdale rehabilitated Nietzsche as a philosopher, and analytic philosophers such as Alexander Nehamas and Brian Leiter continue to study him today.


Friedrich Nietzsche about himself:
Even by virtue of my descent, I am granted an eye beyond all merely local, merely nationally conditioned perspectives; it is not difficult for me to be a "good European." On the other hand, I am perhaps more German than present-day Germans, mere citizens of the German Reich, could possibly be—I, the last anti-political German. And yet my ancestors were Polish noblemen: I have many racial instincts in my body from that source—who knows? [...] When I consider how often I am addressed as a Pole when I travel, even by Poles themselves, and how rarely I am taken for a German, it might seem that I have been merely externally sprinkled with what is German.



“I am a pure-blooded Polish nobleman, without a single drop of bad blood, certainly not German blood."


Is he Polish or German ?

Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 06:25    #2
Polish! :)
JulekcgThreads: 1
Posts: 36
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Julekcg  Oct 17, 08, 06:32    #3
Why you consider him Polish ?
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 07:04    #4
Because he said so?
JulekcgThreads: 1
Posts: 36
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Julekcg  Oct 17, 08, 07:38    #5
Bratwurst Boy:

Because he said so?


His own choice made him Polish ? Maybe we should use his grandfather name Niecki ?
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 07:46    #6
Julekcg:

His own choice made him Polish ? Maybe we should use his grandfather name Niecki ?


Well...isn't that the main argument you use with Kopernikus?
This: "he fighted against the Teutonic Order, he chose the polish side = full blooded Pole" ?

I wonder why you people aren't claiming him too...

PS: I would like to know more about his "polish noble ancestors"...I can't seem to find anything about them!
southernThreads: 116
Posts: 10,955
Joined: May 17, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 07:50    #7
Julekcg:

Is he Polish or German ?


He is too verruckt to be a German.He didn't like Germans for sure.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 07:58    #8
southern:

He didn't like Germans for sure.


Yup...and Kopernikus was black! :)

Are you having fun today southern?

Interesting info:

URL

...
There were two other children in the house. One was a boy, Josef, who was named after the Duke of Altenburg, and died in infancy in 1850. The other was a girl, Therese Elisabeth Alexandra, who became in after years her brother's housekeeper, guardian angel and biographer. Her three names were those of the three noble children her father had grounded in the humanities. Elisabeth - who married toward middle age and is best known as Frau Förster-Nietzsche - tells us practically all that we know about the Nietzsche family and the private life of its distinguished son. ((1)) The clan came out of Poland, like so many other families of Eastern Germany, at the time of the sad, vain wars. Legend maintains that it was noble in its day and Nietzsche himself liked to think so. The name, says Elisabeth, was originally Nietzschy. "Germany is a great nation," Nietzsche would say, "only because its people have so much Polish blood in their veins.... I am proud of my Polish descent. I remember that in former times a Polish noble, by his simple veto, could overturn the resolution of a popular assembly. There were giants in Poland in the time of my forefathers." He wrote a tract with the French title L'Origine de la famille de Nietzsche and presented the manuscript to his sister, as a document to be treasured and held sacred. She tells us that he was fond of maintaining that the Nietzsches had suffered greatly and fallen from vast grandeur for their opinions, religious and political. He had no proof of this, but it pleased him to think so....


It seems there were no polish nobleman in his ancestry (but it pleased him to think so)..:)
southernThreads: 116
Posts: 10,955
Joined: May 17, 07
Edited by: southern  Oct 17, 08, 08:01    #9
Bratwurst Boy:

He didn't like Germans for sure.


This is true.He made comments like ''Marx's sentence was too clever to have been written by a German'',or ''german mind is deep in beer''.
France at that time was full of polish princes.There was the theory that 10% or more of the polish population were noblemen.

Bratwurst Boy:

and Kopernikus was black! :)


I told this for fun to support the panafrican theory that all important ancient philosophers like Socrates,Plato, etc were blacks who incidentally lost their colour.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 08:09    #10
southern:

This is true.He made comments like ''Marx's sentence was too clever to have been written by a German'',or ''german mind is deep in beer''.


He....one must wonder why then he admired Schopenhauer, was friend of Wagner and served in the Franco-Prussian war then etc...I doubt he could have become what he was outside of german schools, german universities, Germany, as he was soaked in german culture, a child of it!

These a bit bitter quotes might have stemmed from some disappointment with his brethren because of that:

In 1883 he tried and failed to obtain a lecturing post at the University of Leipzig. It was made clear to him that, in view of the attitude towards Christianity and the concept of God expressed in Zarathustra, he had become in effect unemployable at any German University.

JulekcgThreads: 1
Posts: 36
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Julekcg  Oct 17, 08, 08:41    #11
Well ... you don't believe in his Polish ancestry. I think it is very possible that he had Polish forefathers.

If we assume that you are right. There is this kind of people inside German society who hate Germany and simple prefere to be Polish. In battle of Gurnwald German comander changed side. German citizens were making pro Polish uprises.
It is very interesting phenomen.

Finaly, without looking on "blood" was he Polish or German ?
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 08:50    #12
Poles making jokes and talking badly of Poland....do you think they hate Poland or are they just disappointed?
I think maybe in Nietzsches time Poland was different and had a different standing...I can't think of any German of today who would wish to be polish, sorry...

I don't know actually what you want to say with all that? Do you think this Commander in this battle (I've never heard of him btw) hated his people?
What's your problem? Do you try to be a 150percent Pole due your family's german heritage???

Julekcg:

German citizens were making pro Polish uprises.
It is very interesting phenomen.


Is it?
Is it uncomprehendable for a "true Pole" to stand by Germans if he thinks it's the right thing to do?
Who is the blind nationalist and hater here? Are the Germans the good guys in truth?

Hello Luki! :):):)
JulekcgThreads: 1
Posts: 36
Joined: Oct 15, 08
Edited by: Julekcg  Oct 17, 08, 08:59    #13
Julekcg:

Lukasz, you will be banned again if you register another account.

I don't know what are you talking about.

Bratwurst Boy:

I can't think of any German of today who would wish to be polish, sorry...


Modern Germany isn't 3rd Reich or Teutonic Order that's the difference.

Bratwurst Boy:

I don't know actually what you want to say with all that? Do you think this Commander in this battle (I've never heard of him btw) hated his people?


He considered himself Pole and thought that Poles were right he didn't hate his people.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 10:01    #14
Julekcg:

He considered himself Pole and thought that Poles were right he didn't hate his people.


Then why did he go to the battle on the Orders side in the first place?
I mean this decision to "be polish" came abit suddenly, didn't it?
McCoyThreads: 46
Posts: 1,756
Joined: Jul 3, 08
 Oct 17, 08, 11:20    #15
cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

And yet my ancestors were Polish noblemen: it is owing to them that I have so much race instinct in my blood-who knows? perhaps even the liberum veto. When I think of how often I have been accosted as a Pole when traveling, even by Poles themselves, and how seldom I have been taken for a German, it seems to me as if I belonged to those who have but a sprinkling of German in them.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

I myself am still too much of a Pole not to resign from all other music apart from Chopin.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

And with this I touch on the question of race. I am a pure-blooded Polish nobleman, in whom there is no drop of bad blood, least of all German. When I look for my profoundest opposite, the incalculable pettiness of the instincts, I always find my mother and my sister—to be related to such canaille would be a blasphemy against my divinity.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

However, even as a Pole I am an incredible atavism. One would have to go back centuries in order to find this noblest of races ever to exist on Earth exhibiting its instincts as pristinely as I exhibit them. Toward everything today that calls itself noblesse I possess a sovereign feeling of distinction,—I would not do the young German Kaiser [Wilhelm II] the honor of being my coachman.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

Vita. I was born October 15, 1844, on the battlefield of Lützen. The first name I heard was that of Gustävus Adolphus [King of Sweden, who fell on the battlefield of Lützen in 1632.]. My ancestors were Polish nobility (Niëzky). The stock appears to have stood up well despite three German mothers. Abroad I usually pass for a Pole; just this last winter in Nice they had me down of the foreigners' list as Polish.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

Germany is a great nation, only because its people have so much Polish blood in their veins.... I am proud of my Polish descent. I remember that in former times a Polish noble, by his simple veto, could overturn the resolution of a popular assembly. There were giants in Poland in the time of my forefathers.

cytuję Fryderyka Nietzschego:

I am more a Pole than I am God


definitely Nietzsche was a Pole :)
MarekThreads: 4
Posts: 1,120
Joined: Feb 15, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 12:00    #16
If only to butt in once again. The question thread might as easily read: Immanual Kant - Scottish or German?

The man's own mother traced much of her ancestry to Scots Presbyterians who settled in German long ago, though Kant himself was born, bred and, as far as we know, NEVER LEFT, Koenigsberg, then quite definitely 100% German!!!

Is he more German than Scots to us, merely on account of the fact that his father's name is German, and he never took his mother's maiden name, probably of Gallic origin??

Seems a double standard, doesn't it?
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 13:22    #17
Well...the Jews claim Einstein for themselves only too even as he was a product of german culture, of german education, of german science....but would he also have become what he was if he had been stuck in some eastern european shtetl??? Highly doubtful!

Maybe that is a criteria! If a Kant's scottish culture and education had made him what he was or Nietzsche's Poles had helped him to think some more we could agree that Scotland or Poland had a more, a better claim...but as with Kopernikus it is a fact that it was german culture, german teachings which shaped them, made their careers possible in the first place. Read their biographies and you will find that most of their contacts, their teachers, their friends were germans.

When an American today wins the Nobel prize, what do I care if he has german roots when his whole life, his education, his culture is totally american? I would never claim him!
Del boyThreads: 22
Posts: 318
Joined: Jun 29, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 14:12    #18
what about Bronislaw Malinowski? british culture?, british education?, british science?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malinowski
Del boyThreads: 22
Posts: 318
Joined: Jun 29, 07
Edited by: Del boy  Oct 17, 08, 14:53    #19
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gumplowicz
Is he was a Jew, a Pole or an Austrian?
His family supported Polish January uprising. He was rejected to get Ph.D degree in Jagiellonian University, so he went to Graz Austria. Who he was? hmm?
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 15:04    #20
Who is claiming those persons?
Del boyThreads: 22
Posts: 318
Joined: Jun 29, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 15:06    #21
be more precise
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 15:50    #22
Who me??? You brought them on! I never heard of them...
Filios1Threads: 15
Posts: 1,953
Joined: Nov 13, 07
Edited by: Filios1  Oct 17, 08, 16:03    #23
Bratwurst Boy:

I never heard of them...


Of course you havn't. Why would German schools teach their good German students about famous Poles?

Bratwurst Boy:

can't think of any German of today who would wish to be polish, sorry


I believe this goes both ways....

Julekcg:


I don't know what are you talking about.


Lukasz? I knew it was you, bracie.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 17:29    #24
Filios1:


Of course you havn't. Why would German schools teach their good German students about famous Poles?


But they do in greek schools? :):):)

Filios1:

I believe this goes both ways....


Enough are coming over...
Filios1Threads: 15
Posts: 1,953
Joined: Nov 13, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 18:19    #25
Bratwurst Boy:

Enough are coming over...


You would truly be lying to yourself if you think thats the reason WHY they are coming....
David_18Threads: 111
Posts: 1,212
Joined: Jan 4, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 18:24    #26
It is amusing to see you people argue about this matter. I hope you all know that Polish and german people have been mixing with each other for over 1000+ years, just because a person is born in Poland/germany dosen't mean he is Polish nore german, he is problably a mix between the countries. Kinda logic dont you think?

@Bratwurst Boy

Did you know that Berlin was an slavic settlement from the beginning, and that both the Chancellery of the Reich and the Reichspalast and aloot of other properties were owned by the Polish nobilty in Berlin before ww2, hurts doesn't it?
Filios1Threads: 15
Posts: 1,953
Joined: Nov 13, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 18:31    #27
David_18:

Polish and german people have been mixing with each other for over 1000+ years,


This is true for the western most provinces of Poland, yes. But as much as everyone likes to believe that there was constant mixing of blood, this is not true. The greatest % of Poles throughout Polands history have always been peasants, and it is no great leap of faith to say that peasants very rarely went outside their own zone of comfort to marry.
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
Edited by: Bratwurst Boy  Oct 17, 08, 18:52    #28
David_18:

@Bratwurst Boy

Did you know that Berlin was an slavic settlement from the beginning, and that both the Chancellery of the Reich and the Reichspalast and aloot of other properties were owned by the Polish nobilty in Berlin before ww2, hurts doesn't it?


Erm...I should be hurt? Why?
Berlin is a wonderful city, was even more so before the war destroyed so much!
I can't fault Poles for coming over, wanting to live here...they do that for millenia now...*shrugs* :):):)
Filios1Threads: 15
Posts: 1,953
Joined: Nov 13, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 19:28    #29
Bratwurst Boy:

before the war destroyed so much!


It got what was coming to it...
Bratwurst BoyThreads: 11
Posts: 14,563
Joined: Apr 2, 07
 Oct 17, 08, 19:45    #30
Well...we rebuild to the most part her former glory!
Now it get's even better with the rebuilding of the old city castle in the town center....:)


page 1 of 3:  1  2  3  Next »

Home / News, Politics / Unanswered [this forum] | Similar


Similar discussions:

Simon Mol is dead:No regrets  GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)!!! OUTRAGE!!!


Random: Is fluency in Polish for an English speaker possible?!

Only registered and logged-in users may post here. Please log in or register.


58 [Guests - 38 / Members - 20] users on live forums now


Home | Unanswered | Archives | Random | Statistics Time in Poland: 21:03 / May 26

About Us | Contact Us | Rules, Privacy | Poland Advertising

© 2005-12 PolishForums.com