Will NATO commit itself in defence of Poland?

you mean will Poland commit to its own defense?

you mean will Poland commit to its own defense?

Was Poland prepared (committed) in 1939?

Absolutely, Poland was prepared, what kind of question is this?

Will NATO commit itself in defence of Poland?

Actually, Poland wasn't prepared. It was gearing up for war, yes - but wasn't prepared.

NATO can't defend a river barge with refugees.

Was Poland prepared (committed) in 1939?

Don't you know? Absolutely, Poland was prepared, what kind of question is this?

Point is a Polish treaty with France and Britain was even more precise than a treaty with NATO.

Poland was supposed to mobilize it's army a month before the German attacked, but Britain and France told them "Don't worry because we have a treaty the Germans won't attack you".

Poland needs to get it in their collective heads that no one is going to bail them out. They need to depend on themselves.

What is Poland doing now to defend themselves from an attack from another country?

What CAN they do?

Start by drafting the unemployed. Base them out of the provinces, have them do basic securty details around Poland, do public works projects, roads, bridges, water systems, etc.

What about USA then ?

Poland needs to get it in their collective heads that no one is going to bail them out. They need to depend on themselves. What is Poland doing now to defend themselves from an attack from another country?

what about them?

Will they commit themselves ?

to what?

no one is going to come with help for sure.

No one is going to defend Poles if we lay down and let ourselves to be overrun.

Our pact with France and Germany had a precise plan military of help those two powers had supposed to provide to Poland

after Soviets invaded, they just let it go!

Point is a Polish treaty with France and Britain was even more precise than a treaty with NATO.

Was as prepared as she could in the circumstances !

As keep saying there is always China.

Well, yeah, and other members of NATO will too, even though NATO is far more than just a defense against the Russians these days.

China's not in NATO

So what is the real threat to Poland ( 2011 ), with the exception of the next invasion of STD carrying English language teachers.

The problem being, Poland cannot defeat Russia on her own. Not if Russia is really committed. There is too damn many of them. We don't have enough people and hardware to even occupy Russian territory, so we cannot dream about straight out military victory.
I believe that we could inflict much more harm on the Russian army then her generals, in their worst nightmares, think it is possible, but if they are really committed, if they buckle up and keep coming, they can soak everything we can possibly throw at them.
Thats why Poland needs these so called defense treaties with other countries. Sure, it would be the best case if no war with Russia ever breaks up (and solid treaties can help with that too), but one cannot build defense strategies based on his hopes alone.