PolishForums.com
POLAND . The Unofficial Guide
Unanswered | Archives
Poland Now and Then Witamy, Guest | PF Members | Gold Members

Polish Forums / News, Politics /

Do you think Tusk will be forced to resign?


page 1 of 2:  1  2  Next » posts: 58

PennBoyThreads: 157
Posts: 3,443
Joined: Dec 7, 08
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 00:24    #1
With Polish youth massively being anti-ACTA and people rejecting many of Tusk's pro German decisions making him look like he listens to everything Merkel says, do you think Poles will demand for his resignation?




WroclawThreads: 77
Posts: 7,404
Joined: Apr 1, 06
 Pictures: 3 [Moderator]
 Feb 10, 12, 00:36    #2
PennBoy:
With Polish youth massively being anti-ACTA


Tusk has apologized for not getting it right. In his speech I noticed that he introduced the word 'internaut' to the population.

PennBoy:
do you think Poles will demand for his resignation?


that demands a seanus type answer. some will, some won't.

The past week or so have shown Tusk that he should not take the population lightly. I think he will serve the full term in office.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 Feb 10, 12, 00:42    #3
PennBoy:
With Polish youth massively being anti-ACTA and people rejecting many of Tusk's pro German decisions making him look like he listens to everything Merkel says, do you think Poles will demand for his resignation?


The youth might be anti-ACTA, but don't forget that much of the anti-ACTA protests were hijacked by PiS supporting hooligans who wanted any excuse to bash the government - even if ACTA is entirely in line with the Dear Leader's principles.

As for rejecting his pro-European decisions - they aren't. Not at all, in fact.

And his resignation? Not a chance - Tusk is firmly in charge of PO. Sikorski is also backing him up - and Sikorski is probably the most powerful man in Poland.
GregrogThreads: 3
Posts: 114
Joined: Feb 2, 09
 Feb 10, 12, 00:43    #4
If u watch demotywatory.pl, kwej.pl. sadistci.pl and other services which are very popular among polish youth/internauts u will see that Tusk have won competition for the most laugh politician. Even Kaczyński has got not so much attention as Tusk. It does't matter what will Tusk say, he has lost a lot because of ACTA.
jasondmzkThreads: 31
Posts: 503
Joined: Jun 1, 11
 Pictures: 3
 Feb 10, 12, 00:44    #5
No. People care more about four years of unprecedented economic growth, more than they care about having their right to steal Avatar off the internets curtailed.
PennBoyThreads: 157
Posts: 3,443
Joined: Dec 7, 08
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 00:44    #6
delphiandomine:
Sikorski is also backing him up - and Sikorski is probably the most powerful man in Poland.

I really don't understand him or can't figure out his intentions, he's some kind of a enigma.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
Edited by: delphiandomine  Feb 10, 12, 00:47    #7
Gregrog:
If u watch demotywatory.pl, kwej.pl. sadistci.pl and other services which are very popular among polish youth/internauts u will see that Tusk have won competition for the most laugh politician. Even Kaczyński has got not so much attention as Tusk. It does't matter what will Tusk say, he has lost a lot because of ACTA.


People have short memories. All it'll take is one more stupid move from Kaczynski and everyone will forget about ACTA and go back to criticising Kaczynski - there are no elections for years anyway. In fact, it sets Tusk up nicely - there will be a declaration of "NOT IN THE NEXT SEJM" for ACTA, and everyone will be "yaay" and vote PO again. Even if they don't, the latest figures show that PO voters are moving to RP, not to PiS.

PennBoy:
I really don't understand him or can't figure out his intentions, he's some kind of a enigma.


Sikorski? His political ambitions were somewhat curtailed by his loss to Komorowski in the PO Presidential primary - he's fine where he is (as a foreign minister with many powerful contacts, with the possibility of the premiership in 2015). He's definitely coming more into his own these days, and I suspect that they're already grooming him as Tusk's successor.
modafinilThreads: -
Posts: 831
Joined: Jun 28, 11
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 00:53    #8
jasondmzk:
No. People care more about four years of unprecedented economic growth, more than they care about having their right to steal Avatar off the internets curtailed.


It wouldn't be a bad idea for the Polish government to feign weakness at the moment. The Zloty has been steaming all year. Only a ultra-right wing government could slow long-term growth.
rybnikThreads: 29
Posts: 1,232
Joined: Jan 16, 11
 Pictures: 4
 Feb 10, 12, 01:37    #9
delphiandomine:
People have short memories. All it'll take is one more stupid move from Kaczynski and everyone will forget about ACTA and go back to criticising Kaczynski - there are no elections for years anyway. In fact, it sets Tusk up nicely - there will be a declaration of "NOT IN THE NEXT SEJM" for ACTA, and everyone will be "yaay" and vote PO again. Even if they don't, the latest figures show that PO voters are moving to RP, not to PiS.


PennBoy: I really don't understand him or can't figure out his intentions, he's some kind of a enigma.

Sikorski? His political ambitions were somewhat curtailed by his loss to Komorowski in the PO Presidential primary - he's fine where he is (as a foreign minister with many powerful contacts, with the possibility of the premiership in 2015). He's definitely coming more into his own these days, and I suspect that they're already grooming him as Tusk's successor.

@ Delph: I've gotta say I don't agree with a lot of what you say but I sure do appreciate your insight. Especially when it comes to Polish politics.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
Edited by: delphiandomine  Feb 10, 12, 01:58    #10
rybnik:
@ Delph: I've gotta say I don't agree with a lot of what you say but I sure do appreciate your insight. Especially when it comes to Polish politics.


I try to - I'm admittedly not a PiS supporter in any way, but I try to view it fairly when commenting on these issues. It probably helps that I don't particularly like any of the Polish parties - I'm a centrist voter, but no party in Poland really is such a thing.

What's interesting to look at is the future of Polish politics - right now, the latest opinion polls are showing a rise in support to 17% for Ruch Palikota. Whether or not this is sustainable is one thing - but it could very well be that people will become less afraid of Kaczynski winning power and some of PO's support will move to Ruch Palikota. Either way, right now, I don't see any way for PiS to return to government unless Kaczynski retires permanently.

What's also interesting is that the opposition right now in Poland has completely run out of ideas - they've been shouting about ACTA being a crisis for Tusk, but in reality, it isn't - especially as PiS supporters were stupid enough to attack a PO building. In fact, the ACTA stuff ran out of steam very quickly when the protests were hijacked by people from the opposition - I know at least 3-4 people who were anti-ACTA who actually refused to be associated with the cause once this became obvious.

You can even see this on this forum - opposition supporters are abusing Tusk, Palikot and everyone else - simply because they haven't got any ideas of their own. It's exactly the reason why the opposition is in opposition - everyone in Poland was sick of negative politics.

But thank you - any questions, start a thread ;)
PennBoyThreads: 157
Posts: 3,443
Joined: Dec 7, 08
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 03:45    #11
delphiandomine:
try to - I'm admittedly not a PiS supporter in any way, but I try to view it fairly when commenting on these issues.

Maybe PiS is a bit too nationalistic and closed minded but I surely don't support PO either. Tusk to me, seams like a buffoon who sells Poland either to Germany or Russia. Poland's weakness was always lack of a strong one man leadership. Poland's neighbors know that a Pole like a Russian will sell his country, his friend or himself to the highest bidder. Germany and Russia are way too involved in Polish politics and want to control it for their own purposes. It's Poland's bad geographical position that makes a need for it to be independent and have a strong powerful leader.
MeatheadThreads: 3
Posts: 196
Joined: Jun 3, 10
 Feb 10, 12, 04:08    #12
PennBoy:
Maybe PiS is a bit too nationalistic and closed minded but I surely don't support PO either. Tusk to me, seams like a buffoon who sells Poland either to Germany or Russia. Poland's weakness was always lack of a strong one man leadership. Poland's neighbors know that a Pole like a Russian will sell his country, his friend or himself to the highest bidder. Germany and Russia are way too involved in Polish politics and want to control it for their own purposes. It's Poland's bad geographical position that makes a need for it to be independent and have a strong powerful leader.


Good observation. Unfortunately what Poland needs is not a strong one man but to do what's right for Poland. The only way to avoid becoming another Greece is too hold on to the zloty.
PennBoyThreads: 157
Posts: 3,443
Joined: Dec 7, 08
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 04:30    #13
Meathead:
Good observation. Unfortunately what Poland needs is not a strong one man but to do what's right for Poland. The only way to avoid becoming another Greece is too hold on to the zloty.


Hold on to the zloty and step out of the EU.
rybnikThreads: 29
Posts: 1,232
Joined: Jan 16, 11
 Pictures: 4
 Feb 10, 12, 04:37    #14
Meathead:
only way to avoid becoming another Greece is too hold on to the zloty.

no
PennBoy:
Hold on to the zloty and step out of the EU.

no
The way to avoid being another Greece is to: 1) live below your means (like Germany did) 2) enforce tax laws = collect all tax monies due. The Greeks are famous for thumbing their noses at tax laws. They've all scammed their way into bankruptcy!
PennBoyThreads: 157
Posts: 3,443
Joined: Dec 7, 08
 Pictures: 2
 Feb 10, 12, 04:43    #15
rybnik:
tax

Petrol in Poland costs something like 2 zlotys 59 grosze, meanwhile people pay 6 zlotys. Not enough tax for you?
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
Edited by: delphiandomine  Feb 10, 12, 04:44    #16
PennBoy:
Tusk to me, seams like a buffoon who sells Poland either to Germany or Russia.


What has he sold? Nothing - apart from privatising some stuff that was long due to be privatised anyway. It's a common conspiracy theory to say that "OMG TUSK IS SELLING POLAND" - but the truth is that most of what can be sold was sold a long time ago.

PennBoy:
Poland's weakness was always lack of a strong one man leadership.


Jaruzelski was certainly a strong leader. Anyway, the political system (which was devised more or less by consensus) means that strong leaders will never gain power - the people very clearly chose consensus politics over strong men. If you listen to most people, they'll tell you the same thing - that Russians like someone holding them by the face and beating them down, but Poles don't.

It's exactly where Jaroslaw Kaczynski failed - he tried to be a "strong man" who used the State apparatus in his favour - and he found very quickly that everyone hated it. It's just not the Polish way - even Sanacja were somewhat consensus based.

PennBoy:
Poland's neighbors know that a Pole like a Russian will sell his country, his friend or himself to the highest bidder.


It was all sold years ago - and it's worth pointing out that plenty was getting sold between 2005-2007.

PennBoy:
Germany and Russia are way too involved in Polish politics and want to control it for their own purposes.


There is barely any Russian involvement in Polish politics. There's some sabre-rattling from time to time, but such is normal from Russia. On a day to day basis, Russia is non-existent. As for Germany - given that Germany is a massive trading partner for Poland, there's always going to be some influence from that direction. It's no bad thing - Poland entered the EU because of German help - it was the Germans who more or less opened the door for Poles to begin with.

PennBoy:
It's Poland's bad geographical position that makes a need for it to be independent and have a strong powerful leader.


Surely a bad geographical position makes it far more important to have good allies, in this case - the Germans - than to be weak and isolated like the II RP was?

Poles don't want "strong powerful leaders" - the last man to try such stunts was kicked out of office very quickly. Look at all the post-PRL Prime Ministers - they have *all* been appointed on the basis of consensual politics - the Contract Sejm operated like that, too. People don't want a "strong" leader who causes trouble - they want someone who can get things done to make the country richer and better.

You'll actually find that PO's biggest mistakes have been when they've attempted to move away from consensus politics.

PennBoy:
Hold on to the zloty and step out of the EU.


Stepping out of the EU would be an economic disaster for Poland. You'd have Poles suddenly required to obtain work permits again, which would mean the labour markets slamming shut for Poland. The EU cash invested in capital projects would dry up, as would much of the EU funded training projects and even business development loans/grants. We'd go back to the days of long queues on all the borders, which would cause people to buy from elsewhere in the EU as the goods don't have to spend hours clearing customs. Overnight, Poland would be suddenly far less competitive - and it wouldn't have the pre-2004 advantage of being ridiculously cheap. Then you'd have the disaster of leaving all the EU schemes such as the Erasmus programme - which would hurt Polish students. And - finally - what about the payments to farmers? They've grown used to the idea of the EU paying them to do nothing in many cases - they would struggle without this cash.

PennBoy:
Petrol in Poland costs something like 2 zlotys 59 grosze, meanwhile people pay 6 zlotys. Not enough tax for you?


Not enough to pay for all the retired people and people on "renta" who don't want to work.
rybnikThreads: 29
Posts: 1,232
Joined: Jan 16, 11
 Pictures: 4
 Feb 10, 12, 04:56    #17
delphiandomine:
Not enough to pay for all the retired people and people on "renta" who don't want to work.

right on!
alexmacThreads: 4
Posts: 60
Joined: Feb 5, 12
[Suspended]
 Feb 10, 12, 07:32    #18
Is tusk a German surname?
JonnyMThreads: 16
Posts: 4,487
Joined: Mar 9, 11
 Feb 10, 12, 07:43    #19
PennBoy:
Tusk to me, seams like a buffoon who sells Poland either to Germany or Russia.

One thing he (or any other politician) can't do is to make Poland an island. They have to work with what they've got which is a country sandwiched between two massive economies.
PennBoy:
Poland's weakness was always lack of a strong one man leadership.

That's the one thing nobody really wants.
rybnik:
The way to avoid being another Greece is to: 1) live below your means (like Germany did) 2) enforce tax laws = collect all tax monies due. The Greeks are famous for thumbing their noses at tax laws. They've all scammed their way into bankruptcy!

Exactly. Poland and Greece are entirely different. Poland is benefiting hugely from access to the EU single market. They won't leave the EU and provided the Euro is in something like its present form they will join it. They already signed up to that as a condition of entry to the single market.

The only question is the level at which they'll enter. Exporters and importers both want entirely different things.

Tusk won't resign. He's the most popular Premier in years, internationally respected and with no credible opposition.
gumishuThreads: 17
Posts: 3,943
Joined: Apr 6, 09
 Pictures: 1
Edited by: gumishu  Feb 10, 12, 08:42    #20
jasondmzk:
No. People care more about four years of unprecedented economic growth,


the years of economic growth have just officially ended - btw growth in Poland was nothing of the sort China (or earlier Taiwan) experienced - the country is poor - the prices are European the earnings are 4 times lower than in Germany on average - there is a huge public debt and there is a retirement fund crisis (the deficit contributes greatly to the debt)

delphiandomine:
"OMG TUSK IS SELLING POLAND"


gas contract with Russia, one - climate package two
gumishuThreads: 17
Posts: 3,943
Joined: Apr 6, 09
 Pictures: 1
 Feb 10, 12, 09:23    #21
answering the title question: I don't know if Tusk is going to be forced to resign - but I will love to see him forced to resign
alexmacThreads: 4
Posts: 60
Joined: Feb 5, 12
[Suspended]
 Feb 10, 12, 09:37    #22
Maybe he is working for the KGB or the Chinese or maybe he is doing what is good for Poland
gumishuThreads: 17
Posts: 3,943
Joined: Apr 6, 09
 Pictures: 1
 Feb 10, 12, 09:57    #23
answering the title question: I don't know if Tusk is going to be forced to resign - but I will love to see him forced to resign
MediaWatchThreads: 31
Posts: 1,305
Joined: Aug 30, 08
 Feb 10, 12, 10:37    #24
PennBoy:
Maybe PiS is a bit too nationalistic and closed minded but I surely don't support PO either. Tusk to me, seams like a buffoon who sells Poland either to Germany or Russia. Poland's weakness was always lack of a strong one man leadership. Poland's neighbors know that a Pole like a Russian will sell his country, his friend or himself to the highest bidder. Germany and Russia are way too involved in Polish politics and want to control it for their own purposes. It's Poland's bad geographical position that makes a need for it to be independent and have a strong powerful leader.


Its true that Poland is in a tough geographical location. I agree Poland has to keep an eye on her neighbors, but since Poland is not in the best geographical location, Poland I believe has to have cordial relations with her neighbors even if Poland disagrees with them from time to time. I think Tusk is aware of that and is walking a thin line trying to keep balanced relations with Germany and Russia. I believe he is doing the best with the political hand he was dealt. Although I think Kaczynski and PiS mean well I think their strong nationalism may compromise a good work atmosphere with Poland's neighbors. Therefore, despite Tusk's flaws, I think he is doing a decent job as a leader.

But other people on this forum are free to correct me if they think I'm wrong.

JonnyM:
One thing he (or any other politician) can't do is to make Poland an island. They have to work with what they've got which is a country sandwiched between two massive economies


Believe it or not Johnny, I agree with you here.


delphiandomine:
try to - I'm admittedly not a PiS supporter in any way, but I try to view it fairly when commenting on these issues. It probably helps that I don't particularly like any of the Polish parties - I'm a centrist voter, but no party in Poland really is such a thing.

What's interesting to look at is the future of Polish politics - right now, the latest opinion polls are showing a rise in support to 17% for Ruch Palikota. Whether or not this is sustainable is one thing - but it could very well be that people will become less afraid of Kaczynski winning power and some of PO's support will move to Ruch Palikota. Either way, right now, I don't see any way for PiS to return to government unless Kaczynski retires permanently.

What's also interesting is that the opposition right now in Poland has completely run out of ideas - they've been shouting about ACTA being a crisis for Tusk, but in reality, it isn't - especially as PiS supporters were stupid enough to attack a PO building. In fact, the ACTA stuff ran out of steam very quickly when the protests were hijacked by people from the opposition - I know at least 3-4 people who were anti-ACTA who actually refused to be associated with the cause once this became obvious.

You can even see this on this forum - opposition supporters are abusing Tusk, Palikot and everyone else - simply because they haven't got any ideas of their own. It's exactly the reason why the opposition is in opposition - everyone in Poland was sick of negative politics.

But thank you - any questions, start a thread ;)


Do you think Tusk is doing a decent job leading Poland?
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Feb 10, 12, 11:45    #25
PennBoy:
step out of the EU.

There is a thousand times less chance of that happening than there is even of Kaczynski coming out of the closet.
peterwegThreads: 35
Posts: 1,997
Joined: Feb 16, 07
 Feb 10, 12, 13:18    #26
PennBoy:

step out of the EU.


No Chance. This is just one of the reasons (the other being security from Russia)

Poverty on the decline in Poland
10th February 2012

The number of Poles who live below the poverty line has declined in the last six years, from 13 million to five million, according to a recent report by Eurostat, the EU's statistics agency.

Such a significant and rapid drop has not been recorded in any other country in Europe, wrote Polish daily Gazeta Wyborcza, which cites the data.

The EU currently defines someone who lives below the poverty line as someone who can't afford to pay for accommodation, electricity and heating, does not go away on vacation, and does not own a washing machine, color television or a phone.

And although 14 percent of Poles currently match these criteria, the country is fairing much better than other European countries such as Bulgaria and Romania where as many as 30 percent are currently living in poverty.

“We have grown accustomed to complaining about a bad situation, and we haven't even noticed that living conditions for many Poles have improved,” Bohdan Wyżnikiewicz, from the Gdańsk Institute for Market Economics, told Gazeta Wyborcza.

According to Mr Wyżnikiewicz, the decline in poverty can be attributed to, among other things, improvements in the job market as well as Poland's accession to the EU in 2004.

“The influx of EU funds has played a huge role as well,” he said.

Eurostat's data indicates that in the last six years the unemployment rate fell in Poland from 18 percent to 10 percent. At the same time the minimum wage increased from zł.849 in 2005 to zł.1,500 in 2012.

http://www.wbj.pl/article-57975-poverty-on-the-decline-in-poland.html? type=
CrowThreads: 367
Posts: 7,316
Joined: Feb 14, 07
 Pictures: 1[Suspended]
Edited by: Crow  Feb 10, 12, 14:45    #27
PennBoy:
With Polish youth massively being anti-ACTA and people rejecting many of Tusk's pro German decisions making him look like he listens to everything Merkel says, do you think Poles will demand for his resignation?

long time ago i informed people of this forum how `Polish` ambassador to Serbia mostly serve to German interests. Now we see that Polish youth awakening. See? Any difficulty that faces Racowie, in a blink of an eye becoming viable problem of Polish people. It was so back before Grunwald and Orsha battles and it is so now. Beware brotherly Poles. Germany and Turkey are behind plot for destruction of Yugoslavia and partition of Serbia. EU follow them and NATO is tool

i would pray for Poland.
CrowThreads: 367
Posts: 7,316
Joined: Feb 14, 07
 Pictures: 1[Suspended]
Edited by: Crow  Feb 10, 12, 21:56    #28
i respect Tusk for one thing. When official Poland recognized Kosovo and practically took part in partition of Serbia, Tusk admitted that Polish government doing so on the pressure from certain world powers. Kind of bravery and elementar dignity was needed for this statement. Anyway, it was his maximum. He stubbed Serbia in the back and he live, while in the same time Lech Kaczinskly who continued to support Serbians even after this statement of Tusk, tragically died. So, in that particular political momentum Tusk obeyed, to say- was realistic and Lech was idealistic. Lech gave his life

In the great game that occurred due to Germano-Turkish plot against Yugoslavia, Lech- aware of Serbian innocence couldn`t allow Poland to take part in such a treachery. He didn`t defend only Serbians, lech Kaczinsky actually defended honor of Poland. He was aware, Poland was betrayed many times and there is nothing honest for Poland to take part in partition of some innocent country, especially if we all know that many bbetrayed Poland, many, but Serbians never.
southernThreads: 116
Posts: 10,958
Joined: May 17, 07
 Feb 10, 12, 23:59    #29
Crow:
He stubbed Serbia in the back and he live, while in the same time Lech Kaczinskly who continued to support Serbians even after this statement of Tusk, tragically died


So Crow would you prefer Tusk to be in that plane and Kaczynski outside?
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 Feb 11, 12, 00:27    #30
Crow:
Lech- aware of Serbian innocence couldn`t allow Poland to take part in such a treachery.


Keep trying, Crow. Unfortunately, those of us who know better know that Lech Kaczynski actually didn't veto the recognition of Kosovo.

Crow:
Tusk admitted that Polish government doing so on the pressure from certain world powers.


Not really. It was more a recognition of reality - that Kosovo was no longer part of Serbia.

Crow:
and there is nothing honest for Poland to take part in partition of some innocent country


Innocent, Crow? Come on...


page 1 of 2:  1  2  Next »

Home / News, Politics / Unanswered [this forum] | Similar


Similar discussions:

Anti-Szymborska hate content  Does Poland support the idea of Slavic unity?


Random: 'to make the game worldwide'

Only registered and logged-in users may post here. Please log in or register.


51 [Guests - 39 / Members - 12] users on live forums now


Home | Unanswered | Archives | Random | Statistics Time in Poland: 23:08 / May 26

About Us | Contact Us | Rules, Privacy | Poland Advertising

© 2005-12 PolishForums.com