PolishForums.com
POLAND . The Unofficial Guide
Unanswered | Archives
Travel to Poland Witamy, Guest | PF Members | Gold Members

Polish Forums / Society, Culture /

K+M+B-2012


page 2 of 2:  « Prev  1  2 posts: 57

HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 6, 12, 22:18    #31
Wedle:
although I think mostly it is just ' tall stories'.

The thing about priests in Poland is that they represent a cross section of the male society, so there will inevitably be good ones and bad ones. And equally inevitably, the bad ones will draw more attention than the good ones.

JonnyMThreads: 16
Posts: 4,487
Joined: Mar 9, 11
 Jan 6, 12, 22:21    #32
Harry:
cross section of the male society

With a preponderance of 'confirmed bachelors'. And if there's one thing I know about queens (and trust me, I know) we like money.
FUZZYWICKETSThreads: 12
Posts: 1,999
Joined: Nov 3, 09
 Jan 6, 12, 22:22    #33
teflcat:
Is 50zł still ok or should I offer more, inflation being what it is and all?


http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,289321,00.html

I'd say you better bump it up a little.
WedleThreads: 24
Posts: 786
Joined: Sep 27, 11
 Jan 6, 12, 23:02    #34
Harry:
The thing about priests in Poland is that they represent a cross section of the male society, so there will inevitably be good ones and bad ones. And equally inevitably, the bad ones will draw more attention than the good ones.


The above is a fair point, I am not going to suggest for a moment that all priests are good ones, there is enough factual stories to prove that some priests over the years have abused their positions, in 2012 who can you trust, can we trust politicians, bankers,doctors,lawyers,accountants, 20 years ago if you qualified in any of these professions, you would be considered a pillar of your community, a forthright person. It is even worse in the USA, you can actually get ordained online http://www.themonastery.org/?destination=ordination.
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 00:36    #35
^ Trust me at least as many of the ones from 20 years ago were utter scum, it's just that then it was easier to hide that fact.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 00:42    #36
Harry:
The thing about priests in Poland is that they represent a cross section of the male society, so there will inevitably be good ones and bad ones. And equally inevitably, the bad ones will draw more attention than the good ones.


Indeed, I could tell you about some real horror stories (in fact, I did tell you!) - but there are some great guys out there too.

I've noticed one thing - the more active a priest is in his community (in terms of doing things, not in terms of interfering) - the better he tends to be. It seems to be very much the ones who are "I'm a priest, bow down and respect me" who tend to be far worse.

Always thought that if the church had an effective mechanism to remove the bad ones and to deal with problems quickly - it would be a real force to be contended with, not only in Poland, but in the whole of Europe.

JonnyM:
we like money.


That explains why you're never in Warsaw to come to the pub :P

To return to the thread somewhat -

What's this about chalking it on the door frame? It's always chalked directly on the door here...
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 00:50    #37
" Always thought that if the church had an effective mechanism to remove the bad ones and to deal with problems quickly - it would be a real force to be contended with, not only in Poland, but in the whole of Europe."
You haven't thought that one through: acknowledge some priests are less than perfect, as if the Catholic church would do that!
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 00:54    #38
Harry:
You haven't thought that one through: acknowledge some priests are less than perfect, as if the Catholic church would do that!


And that's exactly the issue.

The same arrogance caused the Spanish to reject the church, the same in Ireland - guys, learn from your mistakes!

Then again, when you've got people who blindly support everything you do for their own twisted reasons, it's no surprise that certain elements think they're untouchable.
rybnikThreads: 29
Posts: 1,234
Joined: Jan 16, 11
 Pictures: 4
 Jan 7, 12, 01:19    #39
JonnyM:
the wife came home from work to find the priest interrogating her husband about their household income and standing there with a calculator telling him how much they have to pay. And some people actually fall for that!

It's called tithing: 10% of your income goes to the church. The Jews are very strict in that regard. You want to be a member of the synagogue, you tithe 10%. Or so I was told by my Jewish friends.
MeatheadThreads: 3
Posts: 197
Joined: Jun 3, 10
 Jan 7, 12, 06:48    #40
Polonius3:
This formula has appeared over their doorways of milions of Polish flats, as Poles inscribe the presumed names of the Three Kings with chalk blessed in church on the Epiphany.
Such piousd practices including the opłatek sharing, blessing of Easter baskets and blessing of newlweds-to-be by their parents before heading for church are enriching, heart-warming touches that set Poland apart from re-zoologised socieities wallowing in sterile, secularist, materialist scum.


I was raised in a devout Polish Catholic household and neighborhood in Chicago and I can't say I ever seen that inscription above the door. As for the secularist, materialistic scum, these are your fellow human beings. The foundation of Christianity is charity, something the Roman Church conveniently forgets.
pipThreads: 11
Posts: 1,293
Joined: Jul 4, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 08:31    #41
Harry:
Anybody know how common it is for Poles who are outside Poland to put K+M+B-[year] on their doors? More than 20 to 30% or less than that? I'd be guessing from the way that they vote that it would be more but I've never lived in a Polish community outside Poland.


I can't answer for all Polonia but in my experience with the Polish community in Canada- they do put it on their doors also.
legendThreads: 9
Posts: 819
Joined: Apr 23, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 08:57    #42
pip:
I can't answer for all Polonia but in my experience with the Polish community in Canada- they do put it on their doors also.


Yes.
mafketisThreads: 17
Posts: 1,880
Joined: Mar 31, 08
 Jan 7, 12, 10:03    #43
delphiandomine:
have you ever seen this chalked on a "new" flat door?


I have it's on three of the four doors on my floor of a relatively new building (finished around 2005).

I've seen it on others in the same stairway but the layout of the building means I don't see all of them.


delphiandomine:
Opłatek sharing has little to do with religion these days in Poland - it's becoming a secular tradition very quickly.


I'd say it's expanded to secular contexts but that doesn't deprive it of its religious context as well.
pipThreads: 11
Posts: 1,293
Joined: Jul 4, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 11:27    #44
I have seen it on new flats also- built as recently as 2008
The thing about Poland is that religion and culture are so intertwined it seems to be that if a person denies a typical religious custom they are almost denying the culture. I don't think people are returning to religion because of the economic times but rather as a way of returning to the culture- less McDonalds- so to speak.
WedleThreads: 24
Posts: 786
Joined: Sep 27, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 13:18    #45
pip:
The thing about Poland is that religion and culture are so intertwined it seems to be that if a person denies a typical religious custom they are almost denying the culture.


It also works both ways Pip, if foreigners choose to settle in Poland, until the point they have been given Polish passports they are guests of the country and should therefore act accordingly and respect the tradition and values of the host nation, as a good guest should. If I invited someone into my home I expect them to follow the rules of our home, if they are rude or made negative comments about our family traditions,beliefs or values, they would be asked to leave and NOT return.

pip:
I don't think people are returning to religion because of the economic times but rather as a way of returning to the culture- less McDonalds- so to speak.


I can see your angle on a culture-less McDonalds society, it reminds me of a true story about an English guy in Warsaw, every time he would pass the McDonalds with his two boys, he would shout out ' its the devils food ' this became a family joke,his boys are now 11 and 17 and do not eat Mc Donalds, the English guy is a agnostic, so it was not about religious beliefs.. In respect of economic uncertainty and increasing church attendence's. Recession turns peoples lives upside down. It helps them realize that they don’t have a sufficiency unto themselves. Not having a job, not being able to pay the monthly bills, wondering where the grocery money will come from, these are all things that cause even those that are furthest from God to question their own self-sufficiency. They come to a point where they realize that they can’t do it by themselves and seek a higher power.
delphiandomineThreads: 42
Posts: 9,954
Joined: Nov 25, 08
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 13:21    #46
mafketis:
I have it's on three of the four doors on my floor of a relatively new building (finished around 2005).


pip:
I have seen it on new flats also- built as recently as 2008


Thanks guys :)

Wedle:
It also works both ways Pip, if foreigners choose to settle in Poland, until the point they have been given Polish passports they are guests of the country and should therefore act accordingly and respect the tradition and values of the host nation, as a good guest should.


God forbid saying the same thing to a Pole abroad though - we all know how they only choose to respect the bits they like.

Bit like the British, really...
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 13:33    #47
mafketis:
I have it's on three of the four doors on my floor of a relatively new building (finished around 2005).

Zero from three on my floor and zero on the floor below too (building is from 1948).

Wedle:
If I invited someone into my home I expect them to follow the rules of our home, if they are rude or made negative comments about our family traditions,beliefs or values, they would be asked to leave and NOT return.

Your home is your possession, and one which you have worked hard to acquire. Only a few naturalised Poles can make the same statement about Poland.

Wedle:
They come to a point where they realize that they can’t do it by themselves and seek a higher power.

I'm told that opium sales also go up during recessions.
WedleThreads: 24
Posts: 786
Joined: Sep 27, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 13:36    #48
delphiandomine:
God forbid saying the same thing to a Pole abroad though - we all know how they only choose to respect the bits they like.


I quite often visit the UK, therefore it is quite easy to stay in touch with the reality of what is ' moving on ' in my country of Birth. I can imagine it would be very difficult to stay in touch with reality, if you only used the internet,newspapers or others peoples point of view as your source of real information. With time all tradition and values become more modernized with the next generation, this is what is called progress. Some people are willing to accept it, others believe nothing will change unless they change it, then one day they must wake up...
WedleThreads: 24
Posts: 786
Joined: Sep 27, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 13:44    #49
Harry:
Your home is your possession, and one which you have worked hard to acquire.

Agreed, many of us have worked very hard to purchase our property here in Poland, with no leg up from family.

Harry:
I'm told that opium sales also go up during recessions.


This may also be true, I have no source or statistics, people will find a solace or escape in many different ways.
pipThreads: 11
Posts: 1,293
Joined: Jul 4, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 13:46    #50
Wedle:
It also works both ways Pip, if foreigners choose to settle in Poland, until the point they have been given Polish passports they are guests of the country and should therefore act accordingly and respect the tradition and values of the host nation, as a good guest should. If I invited someone into my home I expect them to follow the rules of our home, if they are rude or made negative comments about our family traditions,beliefs or values, they would be asked to leave and NOT return.


I didn't mean insulting ones religion or culture- you kinda lost me here. I just meant that because the Polish culture and religion and we could add war to that mix, is so intertwined that is difficult to pick and choose what is religious and what is cultural. So to deny something that is specifically a religious custom could mean to many family members that they are in fact denying Polish culture- when this is not the intention.
WedleThreads: 24
Posts: 786
Joined: Sep 27, 11
 Jan 7, 12, 14:08    #51
pip:
I just meant that because the Polish culture and religion and we could add war to that mix, is so intertwined that is difficult to pick and choose what is religious and what is cultural. So to deny something that is specifically a religious custom could mean to many family members that they are in fact denying Polish culture


Excellent point, its is the force that you will meet with, when Pols believe you are denying them their history or culture, they have lost so much over the centuries now they are unprepared to let go, we could use Radek Sikorski and his recent comments on Poland's inclusion within Northern Europe, this has been met with vehement criticism from all levels of society in Poland. In many countries it would have been considered a 'rallying call' or 'back to business comment'.
Grzegorz_Threads: 81
Posts: 6,213
Joined: Nov 16, 06
Edited by: Grzegorz_  Jan 7, 12, 15:41    #52
JonnyM:
Ha! My friends moved to Skierniewice and the wife came home from work to find the priest interrogating her husband about their household income and standing there with a calculator telling him how much they have to pay.


Why do you write such bulls*its here ? Do you really think people here are stupid enough to believe in that ?
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 15:45    #53
Grzegorz_:
Why do you write such bulls*its here ? Do you really believe people here are stupid enough to believe in that ?

Yes, of course no priest would ever engage in such behaviour. Just as no priest would ever rape small children.
JonnyMThreads: 16
Posts: 4,487
Joined: Mar 9, 11
Edited by: JonnyM  Jan 7, 12, 16:00    #54
Grzegorz_:
Why do you write such bulls*its here ? Do you really think people here are stupid enough to believe in that ?

Entirely true - and plenty more stories where that one came from. Why do you write such nasty posts - do you expect people to take them seriously?

By the way, do you have K+M+B chalked on your door? And how does this public display of religion affect your daily life?
Grzegorz_Threads: 81
Posts: 6,213
Joined: Nov 16, 06
Edited by: Moderator  Jan 7, 12, 20:47    #55
JonnyM:
By the way, do you have K+M+B chalked on your door?


No.

JonnyM:
And how does this public display of religion affect your daily life?


It doesn't me at all.
IronsideThreads: 59
Posts: 6,789
Joined: Feb 26, 09
 Jan 7, 12, 23:26    #56
Harry:
Anybody know how common it is for Poles who are outside Poland to put K+M+B-[year] on their doors? More than 20 to 30% or less than that? I'd be guessing from the way that they vote that it would be more but I've never lived in a Polish community outside Poland.

I have no idea.
Why would that be of any interest to you.
HarryThreads: 62
Posts: 8,508
Joined: May 2, 07
[Suspended]
 Jan 7, 12, 23:55    #57
^ Poles living outside Poland are often more conservative/traditional than Poles in Poland and I was wondering if this was another example of that.


page 2 of 2:  « Prev  1  2

Home / Society, Culture / Unanswered [this forum] | Similar

BIG LESSON (I visited and was threatened in Poland)  Ephiphany - Święto Trzech Króli


Random: POZNAN; CROATIAN FANS CAMPERVAN PARKING WANTED 09-15.6.2012

Only registered and logged-in users may post here. Please log in or register.


50 [Guests - 43 / Members - 7] users on live forums now


Home | Unanswered | Archives | Random | Statistics Time in Poland: 04:17 / May 27

About Us | Contact Us | Rules, Privacy | Poland Advertising

© 2005-12 PolishForums.com