PolishForums   Polska, Polonia, Poland
Home . Polls . Search Witamy,  [Guest 38.103.63.18]  Latest Discussions . Unanswered Posts
 Please register or login below:

 » Username  » Password 
Polish Forums / Polish Culture /

What's wrong with you, Polish people - is it an inferiority complex?


 [1] 2 3  »»
posts: 86
 
Dice
Edited by: Dice  Dec 14, 07, 18:57  #1

Let me rephrase it: the title should be "What's wrong with us Polish People?" since I'm a Pole like most of us here. So, what's wrong with us? How come that we, Polish people can't get over the "Chosen Nation" bull crap. Why do we have to view everything in the World trough the prism of our Nationality? Why every other subject on this message board must sound something like:

"About the superiority of Polish Culture over the Muslim Culture",
"How dare those German bustards this and that... "
"Those damned Jews - 'enough said"

... And so on and so on.

Hey, I have some news for you - WWII is over for almost 70 years and nobody cares. Poland has never been the Center of the Universe in spite of what we have been told in school and from the family. There are practically zero Jews and/or Muslims living in Poland today, which means that most of you have never even met a Jew or a Muslim, so what the heck are you ******** about?

Is it some kind of an inferiority complex? I know the answer, because we all are suffering from the same disease - yes, it is an inferiority complex.

Member
Posts: 425
Joined: Nov 27, 07
                              
 
z_darius
  Dec 14, 07, 21:14  #2

Quoting: Dice
"About the superiority of Polish Culture over the Muslim Culture",

About the superiority of Germanic race over Slavs

Quoting: Dice
"How dare those German bustards this and that... "

How dare Poles open gas stations in Germany and use Polish Eagle as the trade mark?

Quoting: Dice
"Those damned Jews - 'enough said"

diese Scheiß-Polacken

Yeah, I guess some nations have inferiority complex.

Member
Posts: 2228
Joined: Oct 18, 07
                              
 
plk123
  Dec 15, 07, 00:27  #3

there are jews in PL. open your eyes.

and then tell me what country doesn't look through their 'nationality' prism?

Member
Posts: 3263
Joined: Aug 29, 07
                              
 
_Sofi_ [Guest]
Edited by: _Sofi_  Dec 15, 07, 00:30  #4

Quoting: plk123
and then tell me what country doesn't look through their 'nationality' prism?

I doubt there is one which doesn't :)
Quoting: Dice
all are suffering from the same disease - yes, it is an inferiority complex.

Honestly, the people I know at work show no sign of what you speak of.

Guest

                              
 
Eurola
  Dec 15, 07, 00:39  #5

Quoting: Dice
Why do we have to view everything in the World trough the prism of our Nationality?


Maybe some do? Not everybody. Why are you putting all of us in the same basket?
The 'threads' you quoted are just for the sake of discussion, I think...
I personally don't feel inferior to anybody, superior...maybe -to some loosers..but that's it :)

Member
Posts: 1787
Joined: Dec 2, 06
                              
 
plk123
  Dec 15, 07, 00:44  #6

Quoting: _Sofi_
I doubt there is one :)

ok countries then.

Member
Posts: 3263
Joined: Aug 29, 07
                              
 
_Sofi_ [Guest]
  Dec 15, 07, 00:50  #7

Quoting: plk123
ok countries then.

huh?

Guest

                              
 
plk123
  Dec 15, 07, 01:11  #8

you said you doubted that there is just one. ok name them then..





every contry looks though a prism of their nationality.

Member
Posts: 3263
Joined: Aug 29, 07
                              
 
omniba [Guest]
  Dec 19, 07, 17:02  #9

This is a good question. It would appear, at times, that Poles do have an inferiority complex and perhaps this has something to do with Polish history, going even as far back as the partition. So here is a thought:

When countries are invaded, those who do the physical act of invading are primed by their governments into believing that their task isn’t an immoral one, but that they are actually doing a good service – both to their own nation and to the people of the invaded nation whose leaders are deemed immoral, corrupt, incapable etc. etc.

There is a constant sowing of the seeds of doubt within the invaded nation, and it is very thorough. “Your leaders abandoned you”, “your leaders kept you in ignorance and poverty”, “they sold you out”. The list of the deposed leaders’ sins is long and varied and seeing power corrupts, some of these sins aren’t always purely imaginary.

Then there is the list of the shortcomings of the invaded peoples themselves: the world will be advised of their backwardness, lack of talent, insufficient preparedness for democracy, cowardliness, debauchery, laziness, lack of hygiene, and of course woman-bashing if Muslim (that is one of the newest additions to an invaded population’s sin list).

People in an invaded country are never sure of anyone, be it their neighbour or even a family member. The invader will attempt to buy a subject’s loyalty, and even if unsuccessful will let it be known that the subject is a traitor: again, since people are not saints there will be occasions when this is actually true, to further confound the population. That is one of the best ways to sow doubt. It makes diffidence grow together with constant fear. Even brothers could be potential enemies. It is the principle of “Divide and rule”.

If the invasion is of a sufficiently long duration the sense of worthlessness and diffidence brought about by this systematic indoctrination will creep into the occupied nation’s mentality and culture especially where the invader has made a protracted effort to eliminate the nation’s intelligentsia (cut the head off and the body will flounder). In the long run the result of all this cannot be anything other than an inferiority complex and all that it brings with it.

Could this be, to some extent, what happened in Poland?

Guest

                              
 
gosiaczek
Edited by: gosiaczek  Dec 20, 07, 06:31  #10

Dice wrote:
Hey, I have some news for you - WWII is over for almost 70 years


Don't tell me WWII was the only factor that had an impact on the mentality of Poles. Communism (over for almost 20years) also exerted influence on the way in which Poles perceive themselves as a nation.

Whom do you blame for such a situation? You won't change the mentality of people, they need time to get over their traumas.

Dice wrote:
and nobody cares

?

Member
Posts: 93
Joined: Nov 17, 07
                              
 
jonni
Edited by: jonni  Dec 20, 07, 07:06  #11

gosiaczek wrote:
Don't tell me WWII was the only factor that had an impact on the mentality of Poles. Communism (over for almost 20years) also exerted influence on the way in which Poles perceive themselves as a nation.



Gosiaczek and omniba are right, and I'd go even further. Few countries in the world have had such a stormy (and often tragic) history as Poland, going back hundreds of years, and for much of that time they have shared their territory with many other nationalities.

There have been times when viewing their identity through the "prism of nationality" has saved them.

As a foreigner living here long-term, I can't say that it doesn't sometimes irritate me, but that's the way it is and it's important to get used to that. But with increasing stability, prosperity etc, the next generation here may well change.

Member
Posts: 71
Joined: Nov 27, 07
                              
 
_Sofi_ [Guest]
  Dec 20, 07, 11:10  #12

plk123 wrote:
every contry looks though a prism of their nationality.

That's what I meant too.. that I doubted you would find a country which didn't do that.

Guest

                              
 
Grzegorz_
  Dec 20, 07, 11:23  #13

Dice wrote:
Why every other subject on this message board must sound something like:


Look noob, If you don't like the forums, you may leave any time.

Dice wrote:
since I'm a Pole


How many years have you spent in Poland ?

Member
Posts: 5170
Joined: Nov 16, 06
                              
 
BubbaWoo
  Dec 20, 07, 11:29  #14

jonni wrote:
But with increasing stability, prosperity etc, the next generation here may well change.


hopefully, but the chances decrease if the current generations keep reminding them of it

Member
Posts: 4905
Joined: Sep 26, 06
                              
 
Grzegorz_
  Dec 20, 07, 11:42  #15

jonni wrote:
the next generation here may well change.


Excuse me... Change what ? Open a topic on the international internet forum about French-American issues and Yanks will immidiately start reminding "frogs" that they liberated them during WW2 and now French (and most of the world) are ungrateful sobs, start a disscussion with Jews and It's only a matter of time when they say that you are antisemitic and other crap, Russians believe that "the west" robbed them and want revange, Muslims that "the west" is "Islamophobic" although any western country is much more tolerant than any Muslim country... I could go on for houers, so why the hell could anyone except that Poles should become some biggest friends of humanity and champions of tolerance ? German fans support any team, which is playing against Poland (football, handball, voleyball... any kind of sport) and their media are full of ani-Polish crap, so whay the hell people here should like them ?

Member
Posts: 5170
Joined: Nov 16, 06
                              
 
southern
Edited by: southern  Dec 20, 07, 11:52  #16

Grzegorz_ wrote:
and their media are full of ani-Polish crap


And comedies.



Member
Posts: 3047
Joined: May 17, 07
                              
 
omniba [Guest]
  Dec 20, 07, 13:15  #17

Grzegorz_ wrote:
so whay the hell people here should like them

That may be true, but surely the real issue here is different. The problem is this strange inferiority complex – people with such complexes are not comfortable in themselves or with other people. Perhaps sorting this out or at least understanding it better would lead to a more tranquil view, whether this is through the prism of nationality or anything else, of the rest of the world.

Guest

                              
 
BubbaWoo
  Dec 20, 07, 13:19  #18

omniba wrote:
Perhaps sorting this out or at least understanding it better would lead to a more tranquil view


well said - recognition of the problem is the first step to solving it

Member
Posts: 4905
Joined: Sep 26, 06
                              
 
Grzegorz_
  Dec 20, 07, 13:22  #19

omniba wrote:
The problem is this strange inferiority complex – people with such complexes are not comfortable in themselves or with other people.


So who has this problem ? Where ? When ? How does It look like ?

Member
Posts: 5170
Joined: Nov 16, 06
                              
 
omniba [Guest]
  Dec 20, 07, 15:43  #20

Grzegorz_ wrote:
So who has this problem ? Where ? When ? How does It look like ?

Well, these are the signs of an inferiority complex: sensitivity to criticism, hypercritical attitude, tendency towards blaming, feelings of persecution etc.
An inferiority complex isn’t a sin – it just hampers or spoils rational, calm communication.
Who has it? Too many Poles.

Guest

                              
 
El Gamal
  Dec 20, 07, 15:51  #21

Dice wrote:
"How dare those German bustards this and that... "
"Those damned Jews - 'enough said"

... And so on and so on.

Hey, I have some news for you - WWII is over for almost 70 years and nobody cares.


I don't belive, tahat someone who writes things like this is just dump, it has to be something deeper. Who cares? The Germans. Remember, that all WW2 issue started in late 1990's with German claims, which had to spark torsions in Poland (it's obvious for anybody who has any idea about Polish history of XX century). Germany continues anti-Polish policy, ant an average Germans's idea about Poles is what has been shown in the film and said already. Bastards!!

Member
Posts: 30
Joined: Jul 1, 07
                              
 
slick77
  Dec 20, 07, 15:55  #22

omniba wrote:
Well, these are the signs of an inferiority complex: sensitivity to criticism, hypercritical attitude, tendency towards blaming, feelings of persecution etc.
An inferiority complex isn’t a sin – it just hampers or spoils rational, calm communication.
Who has it? Too many Poles.


bubbawoo fits this profile perfectly and he is not polish, is he? lol

Member
Posts: 177
Joined: Nov 9, 07
                              
 
shopgirl
  Dec 20, 07, 16:01  #23

In sociology there is something called a "culture of victimhood" ....its a kind of syndrome. I don't know if it applies here (it's a rather complex situation). From what I gather the sociological phenomenon deals with an attitude or viewpoint of superiority via martyrdom.

Member
Posts: 1428
Joined: Apr 6, 07
                              
 
omniba [Guest]
Edited by: omniba  Dec 20, 07, 16:04  #24

slick77 wrote:
and he is not polish, is he? lol

I dont know about bubbawoo of course, but there are quite a few non-Poles on this Forum who seem to have quite severe complexes - it is most certainly not just a Polish thing.

Victimhood?

No, that does indeed apply to certain other nations but it somehow doesn't fit the Poles. Their problem is more the fear of being misunderstood. Poland until quite recently was a country "somewhere there" – a sort of hypothetical place the so called “great powers” could bequeath, move, ignore as if it were completely empty. The Poles now aren't really drowning - but they are waving frantically, wanting to be heard and considered. That's different to victim-hood.

Guest

                              
 
Maxxx Payne
  Dec 20, 07, 16:20  #25

Polish inferiority complex ? I dont think so....
For me Poles are nation who are not taking any crap, and thats way it should be.
West is doing its suicide with its leftist PC´ness and west is jealous for people who dare to make a stand.

Member
Posts: 276
Joined: Oct 11, 06
                              
 
slick77
  Dec 20, 07, 16:27  #26

omniba wrote:
I dont know about bubbawoo of course, but there are quite a few non-Poles on this Forum who seem to have quite severe complexes - it is most certainly not just a Polish thing.


Hmm...so, who else in your view is suffering from this inferiority complex?

Member
Posts: 177
Joined: Nov 9, 07
                              
 
omniba [Guest]
  Dec 20, 07, 16:35  #27

:) That would be telling.

Guest

                              
 
slick77
  Dec 20, 07, 16:50  #28

omniba wrote:
:) That would be telling.


Oh, don't be so secretive. Share with us. Tell us who else beside Poles is suffering from inferiority complex?

Member
Posts: 177
Joined: Nov 9, 07
                              
 
Grzegorz_
  Dec 20, 07, 16:52  #29

omniba wrote:
Well, these are the signs of an inferiority complex: sensitivity to criticism, hypercritical attitude, tendency towards blaming, feelings of persecution etc.


X says to Y: You are blah blah blah...
Y denies, so...

Y has inferiority complex... wow.

Member
Posts: 5170
Joined: Nov 16, 06
                              
 
southern
  Dec 20, 07, 16:55  #30

Grzegorz_ wrote:


X says to Y: You are blah blah blah...
Y denies, so...

Y has inferiority complex... wow.


X says to Y:You are an elephant.
Y says,no I am not!
X:Probably you have inferiority complex.

Member
Posts: 3047
Joined: May 17, 07
                              
 
 [1] 2 3  »» Similar Threads¦Latest Discussions Go UPtop of page

Home / Polish Culture /


Only registered and logged-in users may post here. Please login or register.

Newer thread in this forum: Older thread in this forum:
Body hair-depilatories - do Polish women and men use them? Traditional Polish Songs...


89 users online in the last hour [Guests - 50 / Members - 39] All times are CST (GMT -6)

Home . Latest Discussions . Unanswered Posts . Statistics
© 2005-08 PolishForums.com | About Us | Contact Us | Privacy, TOS, Rules | Poland Advertising | Support PF